Can we talk about how in this video Anthony mentions that they never went to their senior prom, instead going to the Olive Garden with their girlfriends who were juniors.
But in today’s lunchtime Ian mentions how he never had a girlfriend in high school. He got one only after high school. Although he never said anything about not having a boyfriend
I don’t know it just seemed a bit suspicious to me…did he or did he not have a girlfriend? Anyways here’s what I believe is possible.
Ian and Anthony dated in high school but when they realized that Smosh was becoming very successful, they mutually agreed to break it off for fear of being judged by a huge audience (remember that this was 2005-06) and which might prevent Smosh from becoming even more popular.
Also, in this old interview we see that they’re very hesitant in answering whether they have girlfriends or not. An explanation for this could be the fake girlfriends theory as mentioned in the Ianthony Report. (Or maybe they were just shy but hey we’re not here to discuss that)
This is just a theory so I’d really appreciate it if no one bashes me for it
I may be overanalyzing but I’d really like to hear your opinions on this.