• pick your choice
nonnie requested: Can you do one where Reader has to choose between Cisco and Winn? Like maybe she’s from Winn’s Earth but Cisco always opens breaches to go see her, and slowly they both fall for her, but she doesn’t wanna choose because she likes them both and doesn’t wanna hurt anyone? She can either end up choosing in the end or not - whichever goes better.
A/N: Ooh very, very interesting concept you have going here nonnie, I like it. This will actually have three parts, this is part one and the two other are where you decide to go stay with Winn or go to Earth-1 with Cisco. Why you ask? Well I couldn’t decide which one reader should go with so I’m going to create two different endings and the fact I love both nerds. And Kara is a goo friend. Warning, it got a little long. And as always requests are open unless stated otherwise by me!
» Relationship(s): Winn Schott & Reader (crushing), Cisco Ramon & Reader (crushing), Kara Danvers & Reader (friendship) «
“And there she is, our Supergirl has done it again folks!” You say with a smile as you high fived Winn as Kara gave a small blush and bowed when she landed on her feet. You were one the people on team Supergirl on Earth-38 who helped save the world, well kind of. You were like Dr. Caitlin Snow from Earth-1 which you may have met once or twice from the last time that both Earths were in dangers, just minus the snow powers. You went over to the blonde haired superhero to check for anything that needed to be treated as you started treating a wound. “Thanks again Y/N.”
She commented as Winn tried his hardest to not stare, but there you were doing what you did best. Winn had a crush on you, Dr. Y/N L/N came into the picture which was a couple months ago when you realized how odd he was acting with Kara. Soon knowing her secret identity after seeing her in her get up of her superhero persona. You were smart and had a certain quirk you had about you that he liked, however he wasn’t the only one who had a massive crush on you. Remember talking about Earth-1? Well on Earth-1 there was another person who liked you and that was Vibe, or better known as Cisco Ramon who was one of the brains on Team Flash. He would sometimes open breaches to see you and ask about Supergirl related things and you would ramble about some things that you could say.