Groban is a better Pierre than Malloy, though. Do you agree?
no, not at all, actually !!!!
i agree that josh groban has a better voice in the traditional sense, but that’s the thing. he sounds amazing, but he doesn’t sound like pierre. pierre as a character is more rough and on edge, and josh sounds too smooth and polished to fit the character. dave’s voice is more gravelly and rough, which is what i usually think of as pierre’s character. so, i agree that from a vocal standpoint josh is better, but dave plays the role more believably.
however, that’s just my opinion. we can agree to disagree.