okay but guys,
Lily Evans knowing the Marauders are animagus’ and she tells all of them (seperately, at different times) that she knows but, they all think they’re the only ones who know she knows.
- So know they all think they’re in on some HUGE secret with Lily
- James thinks he’s totally getting somewhere with her since he told “only him”
- and they all try so desperately to hide that they know
- Sirius is the best at hiding it. Obviously
- Remus is just very very bad at it. I mean, that entire “WEREWOLF? HAHAHA” scene basically played out but with “HOW WOULD LILY EVANS KNOW YOU GUYS WERE ANIMAGUS’????? THATS SO RIDICULOUS OH MY GOD GUYS, PETER! PETER ISNT THAT JUST PLAIN MAD?
- Peter is just a nervous Wreck™ because he thinks that if he says ANYTHING Lily would just immediately hate him and hex him into the next century
- James just wants to brag about how Evans totally likes him since she told him she knew but struggles internally for days
- Lily laughs as she watches them all struggle not to say anything to each other
- She makes weird puns about their animagus form around all of them, “Oh deer…” “Sirius, you dog!” “You’re such a sneaky little rat, Peter!”
- They all sweat nervously every time.
- Remus almost screams when she does it as well.
- It basically ends up with them all screaming “LILY KNOWS.” one day and then they all realize they’ve been played by the greatest gamer of all time. Lily Evans.