All Tied Up
Summary: Theo and (Y/N) have hated each other since the beginning of time and it doesn’t help that he’s with the pack now. Scott and Stiles’ have a bright idea to lock the two in a room together until they make up, but they never expected things to get so heated.
Pairing: Theo x Reader
Word Count: About 2.1K
Warning: Handcuffs, orgasm denial, smut
A/N: Let’s all pretend Theo helped them defeat the Dread Doctors.
Credit to the creator of the gif!
“That’s enough!”, Scott yelled, “You two have been going at it for weeks and it’s starting to get annoying”
“It’s just starting?”, Stiles let out
Scott glared at his best friend before he could continue to chastise Theo and I. Ever since he tried to have Scott killed, I’ve wanted nothing more than to bury him. In the end, he did help us defeat the Dread Doctors, but that didn’t mean I’d just start trusting him.
“She started all of this. It’s not my fault!”, Theo yelled back
“Just like it wasn’t your fault Scott died!?”, I countered
“How many times do I have to apologize? I’m so-”
“Your apologies don’t mean shi-”
“Enough!”, Scott yelled again, his eyes beginning to glow. I knew better then to start yelling again, but this argument was far from over. No one should trust Theo.
“(Y/N) I know this is difficult for you to accept, but he’s a part of our pack now. And Theo, you need to give it time. I’m aware that you two have a history, but somehow you’ll work through it”, Scott reasoned
“That’s not even the reason why!”
“How about some time alone?”, Stiles suggested
Theo groaned, then shook his head, “No, not a good idea”
“You’re right! It’s a great idea”, Scott grins, “Meet me in my room”
I grimaced as Theo smiled politely and led the way. Once we reached his room, Theo plopped down on the bed and made himself at home.
“What?”, he sighed when I glared in his direction
Before I could tear him a new one, Scott and Stiles entered the bedroom with a familiar sac in Stiles’ hand.
“We’ve decided to go on the mission without you”, Scott finally says
“What?”, we yelled in unison
“We don’t need this many people for it anyway. Stiles and I can handle this”
“What if you need backup?”, Theo fired back
“We have a hellhound, banshee, and two betas. In case you forgot”, Stiles replied
“What makes you think we’ll stay put?”, I nearly yelled as Stiles walked closer to the door
He faced my direction as a giant grin spread across his face. Scott quickly grabbed my right wrist and handcuffed it to his headboard, then moved out the door. I frantically pulled my wrist to and fro trying to get out of it.
“Whoa, calm down sweetheart. You might hurt yourself”, Theo said trying to get me to relax, “You know handcuffs won’t work on me. So I might as well leave”
As he began to stand, Stiles dumped the contents of the sac in a line front of the door.
“I doubt you will be anytime soon”, Stiles replied, “Try not to break anything kids”
“Scott be reasonable!”
“I am being reasonable! We’re a team and we need to stick together. Whatever is going on between the two of you you need to work through it. We shouldn’t be gone too long. Don’t destroy my room either”, he said as he shut the door and left the house, effectively trapping Theo and I inside
“Sooooo…:”, I let out to break the silence
“Don’t”, he quickly said, “No small talk”
“Oh so I take it you’re in charge now?”
“Someone should be”, he mumbles
“Aww is someone still mad they aren’t the alpha?”, I smirked as Theo got off the bed to put some distance between us
“Will you quit bringing that up!?”, he shouted
“Why would I do that? You came along and pulled our pack apart piece by piece. Scott died, Lydia was stuck in Eichen House, you blackmailed Stiles-”
Theo stood near the bed with his hands balled into fists, the rise and fall of his chest slightly increasing.
“And you took Hayden from Liam. All because you crave power! Was it really worth it Theo?”
“Be. Quiet”, he sneered
“It must have been worth while since you still ended up on the side of the good guys. Even though it doesn’t wipe away all the bad you’ve done”, I finished
Theo began to tremble as if he was going to break down right in front of me. His eyes flashed yellow and blood dripped from his clenched fist. I’m sure it hurts, but I really don’t care enough to say anything.
“You’re never going to trust me are you?”, he asked quietly
“Not in this lifetime”, I replied, “If you get these cuffs off me, I can break the seal and we’ll never speak of this again”
“No”, he was pacing back and forth, “We’re going to get through this like he said. I know this will take a while, but that’s a risk I’ll have to take”
He was either crazy or cared too much about what happened between us.
“You’re still angry”, he continued, “I know it’s my fault that you’re hurting. Believe me I want to make it up to you, if you’ll let me”
This was a side of Theo I didn’t get to see often. He felt bad for being an ass and wanted to be forgiven.
“No”, I said hesitantly, “You’ve said that before and it didn’t end so well”
He lowered his head and let out a frustrated groan.
“I didn’t know they would take you. If I had known I would have left a while ago”, he said softly
“The only reason you decided to help our pack was because they took me. What if they didn’t? Would you still have helped or let us suffer? You make terrible decisions and I’m always going to be the one to pay for them”
“The Dread Doctors used you to get to me. They thought if they got you out the way, I would be compliant, but it only made things worse. The thought of them harming you drove me crazy and I knew it was all my fault. I stopped at nothing to make sure you would be safe”
He hesitantly moved closer to me and sat on the bed.
“I didn’t mean to hurt you (Y/N). I thought I was doing the right thing until you were kidnapped. Out of all the crap that has been going on you’re the only thing that makes sense and I can’t lose you. That’s why I stayed”
“Why should I believe you?”
“Honestly, you shouldn’t. You have no reason to, but I want to work on us. Find a way to right my wrongs with everyone and that starts with you sweetheart”
He’s never been this forward with me. It was a start and I did miss spending time with him. The late nights. The kissing. God the kissing. It drives me crazy just thinking about it. He leaned forward, his face inches from mine. He was lingering in front of me, eyeing my lips down to my neck and chest. His hands ran slowly up my arms up to my wrists. They ran across the handcuffs, but he didn’t take them off. Confusion spread across my face as he smiled.
Theo moved so he was sitting between my legs and unbuttoned my shirt. As he got closer, he ran the tip of his nose along my neck, I let out a moan. He kissed up my neck as his hand trailed down sliding into my leggings. I couldn’t stop the sounds escaping my mouth. The tip of his finger brushed across my clit and I pulled against the restraints. He smirked as he saw my reaction and began moving his finger in slow circles, but soon picked up the pace. My back arched from against the headboard. He positioned two fingers at my entrance and slowly pushed them in.
“(Y/N) you’re soaked”, he groaned as he finally started to pull out, then push them back in. His fingers went in farther until he found my spot. My legs shook uncontrollably as he continued to rub his fingers against it. Theo kissed me to silence my screams, but soon moved away to watch my reaction. I was getting closer and closer to the edge when he pulled his fingers out and licked them clean.
“Theo please”, I groaned
“Not yet sweetheart”, he smirked as he pulled off my leggings and threw my panties aside
He lowered himself between my legs and softly bit the insides of my thighs. He moved at a painstakingly slow pace as he teased me. Finally, he leaned forward and rubbed the tip of his tongue in circles on my clit. I wanted to keep myself from screaming too loud as I pulled the restraints once again.
“Theo”, I moaned as he wrapped his lips around my clit and sucked gently
His hand yanked my bra down and he rolled my nipple between my fingers. My core began to throb as my moans got louder, then he pulled away with a grin.
“You can’t get too loud, you might wake the neighbors”, he winked
Before I could respond, his lips were on mine once again. He pulled away and his pants and boxers were on the floor. He stroked himself as he stared into my eyes.
“I should have asked you before. Are you okay with this?”, he asked hesitantly
“Yes”, I gasped, “I want this. I want you”
“Thank God because this would have turned out so awkward”, he laughed
His laugh was infectious and I felt myself smiling at him once again.
He leaned over me once more, positioning himself between my legs. Theo pushed himself inside halfway and began to shake. He groaned at the feeling of me being wrapped around him before pushing himself in completely. It didn’t take long to adjust to his length.
He pulled back, then slowly pushed himself in again. His lips met mine once again. Everything he needed to say was in the kiss. The last thing I expected was to have Theo between my legs this evening.
My legs began to tremble. He may have been taking his time, but I could feel my release slowly building up. Just when I thought I reach an orgasm again, he pulled away.
“Are you trying to kill me?”, I gasped
When grinned at me I knew I was in trouble. He lifted one of my legs up, then slammed into me. I barely had enough time to adjust, let alone get a word out. As he continued his pace, I was far from able to form a coherent sentence.
He moved his hand to get a hold of my waist at an angle. As he began to hit my spot again, I let out another moan, barely able to control myself. By now I was screaming his name.
Theo leaned down to kiss my neck when I heard him growling softly in my ear. He couldn’t control himself either. I pushed my hips up to meet his pace and he growled even louder.
“(Y/N) I’m so close”, he groaned
The look on my face told it all. With my movements matching his torturous pace and his lips on my neck, I was pushed over the edge and Theo quickly followed suit. He collapsed on top of me trying to catch his breath.
Soon the cuffs were broken and we scrambled to put our clothes on once we heard the front door open. Theo and I smiled as we raced to put Scott’s bed back together. As soon as we finished, the door pushed open.
“We’re back”, Stiles called as he broke the seal
Scott hesitantly stepped into his room and looked around, “You took her cuffs off”
“Yeah. They weren’t needed…after a while”, Theo said, a knowing grin spreading across his room
Scott paused again, then breathed in. His eyes widened as his gaze landed on the both of us holding hands.
“Did you two…in my bed!?”
Stiles doubled over in laughter, “I never saw that coming”
“Scott, I never planned on this happening, but one thing led to another and…”, Theo stated
“Look in the bright side. We get along now. Isn’t that what you wanted?”, I said grinning from ear to ear
Scott opened his mouth, but nothing came out as he glared at the both of us.
“Babe”, Theo said as he squeezed my hand, “We should run”
With that being said he pulled me out of Scott’s room and run like hell with Scott chasing right behind us.