DM (me): The wolf leaps at Bryn (the party’s paladin)
I roll for the wolf’s attack… and get a one. I gasp and the party get’s this look of dread, likely thinking I crit.
After a brief pause I continue:
DM: The wolf sails through the air towards Bryn… *I let the suspense hang in the air* and face-plants against the tree behind her.
Paladin: Did you roll a one??!
DM: I absolutely rolled a one!