Imagine splitting up from your brothers.
A/N: This takes place S1E10, Asylum.
Dean x Sister!Reader Sam x Sister!Reader
You kept your eyes peeled for the ghost that was trying to talk to Dean; waiting for her to reappear. Sam was going on about how she didn’t try to harm Dean, how it seemed that she just wanted to talk to him, but you tuned him out.
You’d been giving both brothers the silent treatment ever since leaving Kansas. Things had only gotten more awkward after finding out about your disappearance from their lives for almost three years when you were an infant. A secret they had kept from you for years; that, along with Mary’s spirit stirring up emotions, had led to you where you are now; ignoring both your brothers existence.
Sam continued talking but stopped when you all heard the same noise. Dean held his shotgun at the ready while Sam quickly moved an old hospital bed out of the way, revealing a scared blonde who looked like she was the same age, maybe a few years older then you.
“Hey, it’s okay.” Dean said, “We’re not gonna hurt you. What’s your
“Katherine, Kat.” She replied, looking between the three of you, intimated by the two large men.
“I’m Dean and this is Sam and Y/N.” Dean told her. Sam sent her a small smile while you gave her a confused look, wondering why she was there.
“What are you doing here?” Sam asked her, wondering the same thing as you.
“Um, my boyfriend, Gavin-” Kat began but Sam cut her off.
“Is he here?” He questioned, concerned about someone being alone in the asylum.
“Somewhere. He thought it would be fun to see some
ghosts. I thought it was all, ya know…” She said while making a face.
“Make believe?” You asked her.
“Yeah. I’ve seen things, then I heard Gavin scream
and-” Kat didn’t complete her sentence, she began to look around the building and you could tell she was scared.
“Alright, Kat come on. Y/N’s gonna get you out here
and we’re gonna find your boyfriend.” Dean told her.
“No! I’m not leaving without Gavin!
I’m coming with you!” Kat shouted at the three of you. You raised your brows and gave her a look, impressed that she was standing up for herself but annoyed with her stupidity.
“Look, Kat, it’s no joke around here okay? It’s dangerous.” Sam told her.
“That’s why I gotta find him.” She responded. The three of you shared a look, you shook your head no but your brothers ignored it. Letting out a loud sigh you ran your fingers through your hair, freaking unbelievable.
“Alright. I guess we’re gonna split up then. Y/N/N,
Kat, you’re coming with me. Sam, you go find Gavin.” Dean stated.
“No.” You declared.
“I’m sorry, what?” Dean asked, shocked that you were going against his orders for the first time ever.
“I said no. You and Kat can go together, Sam can be on his own and so can I. We can cover more ground this way.” You told him as you flicked your flashlight back on. “Call me if you need me.” You said, not giving him a chance to reply before walking down the hallway.
Dean placed his hand on his forehead before rubbing his face in annoyance, “Being on the outs with her is a bitch.” Dean told Sam who simply let out a scoff.
“Yeah, welcome to my life.”
Tags under the cut