Chancellor Bethmann Forced Out by Hindenburg & Ludendorff

The new Chancellor, Georg Michaelis (1857-1936).

July 13 1917, Berlin–Nearly three years into the war, some in Germany were realizing that their chances of winning were slim.  The revolution in Russia, and their call for a peace without annexations or indemnities (not to mention American entry under Wilson) seemed to offer a way out.  On July 6, Matthias Erzberger, a Zentrum politician who had unfailingly supported the war, told a committee of the Reichstag that unrestricted submarine warfare was not working and would not work to knock Britain out of the war.  Germany’s only way out of losing the war would be to trade the occupied territories in France, Belgium, and Poland for a peace.

Erzberger soon convinced the Reichstag, and it was clear that he had a large majority behind him for a draft resolution, reading “The Reichstag strives for a peace of understanding between the peoples….Forced territorial acquisitions and political, economic, or financial oppression are irreconcilable with such a peace.”  Chancellor Bethmann, although he had argued for peace last year, did not support the measure.  Now was not the time, in Bethmann’s view; Russia, the country most likely to entertain this idea, was enjoying success in the East with the Kerensky Offensive, and such a proposal would be a sign of weakness.

Hindenburg & Ludendorff were in extreme opposition to the measure, as well.  Although they were not sanguine about Germany’s chances in the war, they believed such a measure would greatly hamper the troops’ morale, as they thought it had in Russia.  They offered their resignations, a common tactic of theirs.  While the Kaiser fumed at “this kind of behavior,” he believed that they were too popular and too important to lose, and he did not accept their resignations.

Bethmann, meanwhile, came to the realization that he no longer had any true authority.  The showdown over the peace resolution demonstrated that he did not have the support of the Reichstag, and that true power in Germany rested with Hindenburg & Ludendorff anyway.  On the morning of July 13, while Hindenburg & Ludendorff were on their way to Berlin, Bethmann resigned.

A number of candidates were mooted for his replacement.  The Kaiser rejected Bethmann’s predecessor, von Bülow, due to a long-standing grudge over the handling of one of the Kaiser’s many gaffes in 1909.  Others declined for the same reasons Bethmann resigned in the first place.  Hindenburg & Ludendorff rejected Bernstorff (too dovish) and Tirpitz (too much of a threat).  The new chancellor, Georg Michaelis, an essential unknown, previously in charge of Prussian food administration.  He was able to water down the peace resolution to the point where it no longer seemed binding on the German government.

Today in 1916: Greek Royal Palace Burns Down; King Narrowly Escapes
Today in 1915: Germans Launch Assault Towards Narew River in Poland
Today in 1914: Wiesner Report on Assassination Finds Extensive Serbian Black Hand Involvement; No Evidence of Serbian Government Involvement

Sources include: Robert B. Asprey, The German High Command at War.


Realistically Colorized Historical Photos

Here are some of my favorites since they are so hauntingly beautiful.

1) Thich Quang Duc’s self-immolation, 1963 (Photo credit: Sana Dullaway)

2) Hindenburg Disaster, 1937

3) Japanese Archers, circa 1860 (Photo Credit: Jordan Lloyd)

4) Operation: Crossroads Atomic Detonation (photo credit: Sana Dullaway)