Three people check into a hotel room. The clerk says the bill is $30, so each guest pays $10. Later the clerk realizes the bill should only be $25. To rectify this, he gives the bellboy $5 to return to the guests. On the way to the room, the bellhop realizes that he cannot divide the money equally. As the guests didn’t know the total of the revised bill, the bellhop decides to just give each guest $1 and keep $2 as a tip for himself. Each guest got $1 back: so now each guest only paid $9; bringing the total paid to $27. The bellhop has $2. And $27 + $2 = $29 so, if the guests originally handed over $30, what happened to the remaining $1.
The key to understanding the riddle intuitively is to realize that, while each man did pay $9, he did not pay $9 to the hotel. Each one paid $8⅓ to the hotel ($8⅓ × 3 = $25), and $⅔ to the bellhop ($⅔ × 3 = $2), for a total of $27 spent by the group. $25 + $2 = $27, and so does $9 × 3.
The initial payment of $30 is accounted for as the clerk takes $25, the bellhop takes $2, and the guests get a $3 refund. It adds up. After the refund has been applied, we only have to account for a payment of $27. Again, the clerk keeps $25 and the bellhop gets $2. This also adds up.
There is no reason to add the $2 and $27; the $2 is contained within the $27 already. Thus the addition is meaningless (mixing cost and cash). Instead the $2 should be subtracted from the $27 to get the revised bill of $25.
This becomes clear when the initial and net payments are written as simple equations. The first equation shows what happened to the initial payment of $30:
Both equations make sense, with equal totals on either side of the equal sign. The correct way to get the bellhop’s $2 and the guests $27 on the same side of the equal sign (“The bellhop has $2, and the guests paid $27, how does that add up?”) is to subtract, not add:
This question is very simple when thought of in a different manner. The hotel receives $30 from the guests and gives $5 to the bellhop to return to the guests. $30 minus $5 equals $25. $3 is given to the guests and the bellhop keeps $2. Thus, $3 plus $2 equals $5, and the remaining $25 is in the possession of the hotel.
This is clearly not a paradox, and involves only the switching of subtraction for addition. Each patron has paid $9 for a total of $27. The storyteller adds the $2 that the bellhop pilfered, but he should have subtracted the $2 to make a total of $25 paid. So 3 × $9 = $27, which accounts for the $25 room and the $2 given to the bellhop.
Supporting Sam’s choice to go to college had been hard, but Dean gave up hunting for it. He knew that the kid’s scholarship covered school, but it couldn’t cover fun money, and not to mention the geek would probably end up living in the library without his brother there to take care of him. Also there was no way he’d let his little brother get shuffled into the dorms with who knows who as a roommate, so Dean had gotten a job as a bartender to pay for the apartment he and Sam lived in, and occasionally he’d help out at the car shop down the road for when tips weren’t enough.
He got to meet all sorts of folks in the bar, and it wasn’t so crappie dive of a place that hunters would go to it was a party bar for the college kids, and sometimes he could get the richer kids to tip him a lot more than necessary by doing tricks while he made their drinks or getting them to dare him to do things. Still he had the most fun getting some of the jocks all rolled up by flirting with both their girlfriends and them, and then turning around to the philosophy major to help him remember his way home as he left.