Secrets & Betrayal
Requested by @fallenfairy16
Note: I started typing this up as soon as I read your message - I am amazed at how quickly some ideas come to me sometimes lol! (hence the delay in actually replying to your message). Hope this answers your request!
Peter Pan x Reader
Warnings: Nothing other than a small amount of unwanted advances.
You thought you had been careful, that no one would ever find out, but you hadn’t taken into consideration the fact that Tinkerbell had seen you numerous times. The ex-fairy was close to Pan, had always been trusted by him, so you were not surprised at all that she had gone running to him. She had always wanted him to like her. It was quite pathetic how much she ran to him actually.
“There is no such thing as a secret.”
You are standing before Peter himself, in the camp that he had allowed you to stay in with his Lost Boys, but instead of wandering it freely as you once did you find yourself tied to a tree with rope that he had made appear out of nowhere with a simple wave of his hand. The look in his eyes is the darkest you have ever seen and given that you have seen him mad on more than one occasion this is definitely something new and something rather terrifying for you too.
You have seen first-hand what he was capable of when he was angry.
“I have never had many rules on this island [y/n], you know that, but what was the FIRST thing I said to you when I gave you a home here?”