Authors Note: The second part just kind of popped into my head so here it is. Let me know if you want me to write a third. :)
Jensen refused to leave you alone so you got out of your car and tried you hardest to look like hadn’t just spent the last 10 minutes crying.
“Jensen why are you still here?”
“Because I want to explain.”
“Oh you want to explain. You want to explain why you cheated on me with my best friend? Not just once but multiple times over the past what 6 months!”
Jensen took a couple steps back and rubbed his hands down his face. When he looked back up at you, you could see tears starting to form in his eyes.
“I love you Y/N.”
“No. No Jensen. You don’t get to say ‘I love you’ and think that it’s going to make everything better.”
Now you were the one trying not to cry… Again
“I know it’s not going to make everything better, but I still want to be with you. You are still the love of my life and I know I screwed up. God, did I screw up, but you’re still the girl of my dreams.” He walked toward you and started to hesitantly push your hair out of your eyes. “You’re still the one that I want to wake up to every single day. You’re the one that I want to sit on the front porch with when were 60 and watch our grandchildren play in the yard.”
“Jensen stop. You have to stop. You… You cheated on me. What am I supposed to do? Go on and pretend that it never happened? Do you know how much it hurt to find out from my little sister!? You weren’t even the one to tell me. Were you ever going to tell me?”
He stood there in front of you trying to decide whether he was going to tell you what you wanted to hear or the truth.
“No. I was never going to tell you. I kept telling myself that it was never going to happen again.”
You couldn’t even stand to look at him right now you had to get away. You started walking, no destination in mind.
“Y/N! Is this it then?”
You kept telling yourself not to turn around, that you would regret it.
“Is this how it ends?”
You stopped and turned around to see Jensen with tears rolling down his face.
“I don’t know Jay.”
He ran up to you wrapping one arm around you and hooking his finger under your chin so you had to look him in the eye.
“Baby this can’t be it. I need you. You’re my whole world. I’m nothing without you. With Lesley, it was just sex. I will never love anyone the way I love you.”