gif: second invasion

Your argument is invalid

I feel like the phrase “Jamie McCrimmon. Your argument is invalid” is a useful rebuttal to all sorts of things. For example:

“Classic Who was a bunch of screaming, pretty girls.”

“Jamie McCrimmon. Your argument is invalid.”


“Male companions just don’t work as well.”

“Jamie McCrimmon. Your argument is invalid.”


“We don’t have historical companions because people can’t identify with someone from a different time period.”

“Jamie McCrimmon. Your argument is invalid.”


“Why do we have to keep focusing on old companions? The Doctor just used to move on.”

“Jamie McCrimmon. Your argument is invalid.”


“Classic Who didn’t have character development”

“Jamie McCrimmon. Your argument is invalid.”


“Classic Who lacked emotional depth.”

“Jamie McCrimmon. Your argument is invalid.”