Yoooo! I am responding to your discussion. What is your absolutely raw feelings towards John having another son with another woman and never mentioning it? Like do you think that it was a good idea he didn't mention it and pull Adam into all the hunting and stuff or was it wrong?
hmm like tbh when you look at it from Adam’s POV, it’s a good thing. Adam actually lived as a normal kid, and John was an okay father for him.
but from Sam & Dean’s POV, it’s horrible. If John could stop Adam from hunting, he could have been nicer to Dean & Sam. Hell, he could have told them and they’d have all lived together.