Who would win in a swordfight between Feanor and Fingolfin? Who would win in a monomachy between Orome and Eonwe? Gandalf the White vs Tulkas?
1. I’ve always imagined Fingolfin as kind of taller and stronger (possibly because I imagine Miriel as more slender and Indis as more Amazonesque) but I realise now that this is almost entirely headcanon? Fëanor’s a smith (granted, most of the stuff he makes is quite delicate, but still I imagine he has pretty great shoulder muscles) and has a lot more life experience in which he might have started on someone with a sword. Let’s be honest, out of the two of them, in Valinor,
definitely the one more likely to have done this before, whereas Fingolfin…just…does whatever people usually do in Valinor?
I am too Edain for this how do people Valinor
Anyway, there’s that, but then there’s also the fact that of the two, Fëanor is much more likely to completely flip out and just charge on pure passion. I have no idea if this would help or make it worse?? I actually don’t have a clue, what I like about Fëanor is you just can never quite tell.
My head says Fingolfin, my heart says Fëanor, my soul says drop this question it’s loaded and the safety catch is off.
2. OKAY THAT WOULD BE A SWEET FIGHT, I almost don’t care who wins as long as I can watch. From a safe distance. Holding a large flag that says “YAY
EÖNWË” and playing a vuvuzela. I lied I care who wins. I mean Oromë
is a Vala yes, but hunting is different from fighting, and I think
is better suited to battle. If
can catch Morgoth offguard then it could happen. Maybe.
3. The answer to this question is Tulkas. Gandalf I’m really sorry bro.