Innocent? Not Really.
Theo Raeken x female!Reader
Fandom: Teen Wolf
Request: “Could you make a Theo Raeken smut where the reader is a really innocent good girl and she is Stiles sister? One night Stiles and the pack are at a party and Theo takes his chance to get the reader alone and finally do what he’s been wanting to do with her? Please and thank you so much!”
Warnings: Smut & language
So, tonight, my brother decided that he is going to throw a part. Fantastic.
“It isn’t really a "party”, Y/N/N. It’s just the pack getting together to hang out.“ Stiles ran behind me while I walked to the jeep.
I rolled my eyes. "Fine, whatever. Can I drive?”
"Are you high?!“ Stiles held his key above his above his head, out of my reach.
I jumped up and down trying to get the jeep keys. "Come on, Stiles! Don’t be so mean!”
Lydia, Scott, Allison, and Theo walked up to my brother and I.
“Um, is everything okay here?” Lydia looked between the two of us.
“Stiles is being a dick!” I huffed.
Lydia gasped dramatically. “That was a naughty word, Y/N!”
I rolled my eyes and pushed passed the two giving me grief. Theo stuck out his arm and pulled me into his chest. I stood on my tip toes to wrap my hands around his neck and hug him back.
“Don’t worry about it, Y/N/N. They are just being assholes.” He squeezed me.
I smiled.“ Yeah, they do it all the time, it’s nothing I can’t handle.” I pulled away from Theo.
“Are you coming over tonight?” I asked.
Theo rubbed the back of his neck. “Y-Yeah. I mean, uh, if you want me to, I will.”
I smiled, showing my teeth. “That’d be amazing!”
“Y/N! Let’s goooooooo!” Stiles honked his horn at me.
“I gotta go. I’ll see you later tonight?”
Theo kissed my head and nodded. "Of course. Don’t get into any trouble, Little Miss Innocent!“
I laughed out loud and jumped in the jeep.
Stiles put some snacks on the living room table. I sat on the couch, staring at my phone.
"Are you going to help me or?” Stiles stood with his hands on hips.
I smiled and quickly typed on my phone. “No, sorry. I’m busy.”
“Doing what?! Everyone will be here any second and you are just sitting there texting! Who are you even talking to?” Stiles snatched my phone away from me.
“I wouldn’t!” I warn.
Stiles read the messages.
I watched my brothers face get red and heard the front door open. Scott, Allison, Derek, Lydia, and Theo came in. Theo’s eyes instantly met mine. I threw my head in the direction of my brother. Theo looked and saw Stiles holding my phone in his hand. The two of us started to bust out laughing.
The pack took their shoes off and chose their seats. Theo slumped on the big chair with me. I sat with my back resting against the arm of the chair and my lower body draped across Theo’s lap.
Stiles turned off the lights and popped the disc in the DVD player. The previews to the movie started.
“Are we watching fucking Star Wars again, Stilinski?!” Scott yelled.
“Yes, McCall! Now shut the fuck up and watch the movie!” My older brother yelled back at Scott.
Scott mumbled. Stiles leaned forward from his seat next to Derek. “I don’t know what you just said, but we could all be dying instead, so count your blessings!”
I picked up my cup. “And I could be riding Theo’s dick, but whatever.”
The choked on whatever he had started eating a few seconds ago. Everyone turned their heads to us.
“Is he alright?” Allison asked.
Theo coughed some more. “I’m fine! I just clearly can’t eat right.”
I felt my ears get hot. Theo leaned to me. “Where did that come from?!” He whisper-shouted.
I whispered back. “I honestly don’t really know. I didn’t think you’d hear me! And I need you to move your phone, please.”
Theo pause for a second. “Y/N…that isn’t my phone.”
I squinted. “What?”
Theo took my hand and moved it to where I thought his phone was. As soon as my hand touched the bulge, I knew exactly what it was. I felt my underwear get wetter.
“Oh…” I said.
Theo let my hand go and rested his on my upper thigh. “I really like you, Y/N. I like you so much that it is actually hard to put into words. You are so damn pretty that every time I see you it makes my heart stop. The fact that you aren’t my girlfriend drives me fucking insane, Y/N. And right now, all I can think about it fucking you senseless.” He whispered in my ear.
I smirked. “I’m game.”
Theo growled, and I felt myself get wetter. We snuck upstairs to my room silently. Theo closed the door with his foot quietly. He picked me up and I wrapped my hands around his neck.
Theo and I leaned together. Our lips connected and the kiss sent sparks through my body.
Theo gently placed me on the bed and pulled away from me. I bit my lip as I watched him pull off his shirt. I sat up to take mine off too. Theo stopped me.
I rose my eyebrow at him.
“Be mine, Y/N? I need to hear you say yes before we go any further. I meant what I said about liking you while we were on the chair.” Theo held my waist.
I smiled wide. “Of course, Theo. I’ve wanted to be with you since we met.”
Theo pecked my lips and let me finish taking off my shirt.
Theo cupped my breasts. “This is a pretty bra, Y/N…but I think it’ll match the floor a little better.”
I rolled my eyes at Theo. He removed my bra and licked his lips. I squirmed in my seat a little bit.
Theo leaned forward and took my boobs in his hands. I moaned quietly and rolled my head back.
Theo groaned. “God, Y/N. You are so fucking beautiful.”
I crawled up to the top of the bed. I used one finger to beckon Theo to me. He climbed up to me and kissed me. His lips unlocked doors in me that I had long forgotten.
Theo pushed his crotch into mine. I gasped.
“Can you, u, help me out with that, baby?” He bit his perfect, pink lip.
I smirked. “Only if you make it hard for me to walk tomorrow.” I whispered.
Theo moaned. “Jesus, Y/N. I thought you were an innocent good girl.”
I grabbed Theo’s dick through his pants. “Oh, babe, good girls are just bad girls who haven’t been caught.”
Theo shot up and undid his belt faster than you could imagine. He took off his jeans next and tossed them somewhere in my room. He took out one claw and tore my cloth pants and underwear in half.
Theo slid a condom over his hard on and crashed into my lips.
“Theo..fuck me…I want to feel your cock inside of me.” I panted.
“Do you want me to go slow, baby?”
I grinned. “Fuck, no.”
Theo rammed his cock inside of me. I bit his shoulder to keep from screaming out. I drug my nails down Theo’s back roughly.
Theo’s cock stretched my walls and made me a moaning and panting mess.
“Harder, Theo. Please, fuck me harder.”
Theo put one of his hands over my mouth and the other by my head. He thrust into me with more force. I closed my eyes, overwhelmed with pleasure.
“No, no, no, Y/N. Look at me while I fuck you in your tight, little pussy.”
Theo’s words made me moan super loud in his hand. The feeling of Theo hitting my g-spot with every thrust made it hard to keep my eyes open, but I managed to do it anyway.
“Look at you, Princess.” Theo praised. “You take my huge cock so well. Your pussy looks so good wrapped around my shaft. Fuck.”
I moaned and dug my nails even deeper into Theo’s shoulders.
Theo moved his hand from my mouth. “T-Theo. Oh, fuck, you make my pussy feel so good. Please don’t stop.”
I didn’t think Theo’s thrust could get any harder, but they could. Theo thrusted harder and put a hand on my headboard so that the group downstairs wouldn’t hear it hit the wall while Theo pounded into me.
I gasped as I felt myself start to cum. I arched my back and pressed my chest against Theo’s. My toes curled and I groaned louder than I should have. Theo started to get sloppy and thrusted into me a few more times. He groaned in the crook of my neck. I felt his cock pulsate in my pussy when he came.
Theo pulled out of me and we both collapsed on the bed next to each other.
The condom got tossed in the trashcan next my bed. I snuggled into my boyfriend’s chest. “Well,” Theo smiled at me. “not really all that "innocent” are ya, baby?“
I kissed his chest. "Babe, I promise that only you will see me like that.”
Theo kissed my head. The living room light flicked on and some of it shone under my door. “Hey, where are-OH, FUCK NO! Y/F/N Y/M/N STILINSKI!” My brother started up the stairs.
“If he liked me before, he sure as shit is going to hate my guts now. ” Theo joked and I hid under my blanket.