Fanmixes! A How-To Guide.

So if there’s one nerdy shameful trash habit I have, it’s making fanmixes. I recently got back into them after not doing them for a while, and I thought I’d share some advice about fanmixes, how to make a good one and why they’re cool and good! 

What is a fanmix??

So you’re HARDCORE into some crazy fandom. Let’s call it The Amazing Antics of Stupid-Kun. You hang out on tumblr, you reblog the fanart, you browse ao3 at night for smutty fanfiction. You may or may not be serious when you say you’re trash and should be thrown into the garbage. THAT’S how much you love this fandom. And the one day you’re in the car and a song comes on the radio

“My god!” you say “This is the PERECT song for Stupid-Kun!”

Fanmixes’ are taking that part to the extreme. It wasn’t enough that you started to find songs to fit this show/character/pairing. You found multiples. Enough to make a mix-tape. And you decided to subject this  list of music to anyone else who loves good music and The Amazing Antics of Stupid-Kun.

It sounds a little silly, (and it is), but there is a job similar to it in the entertainment industry called a Music Supervisor, so it’s not that bad.

Much like that rhyme about the Little Girl with the Little Golden Curl, fanmixes can be great, or they can be awful. Your millage might vary with personal music taste, but they’re a fun way to participate in fandom and also to share some sweet ass music with the rest of the internet nerds. I’ve been making fanmixes for over ten years now, and I thought I’d give a write up for what works for me, how to get the best out of your mix!


Obviously your millage may vary, but I find fanmixes themselves to be a GREAT way to get into new music. I’d say I owe a lot of my developed music tastes to other fanmixes I heard back when I was getting into this. I’ll be blunt here. It’s 2015, there is NO reason your fanmix needs to be composed of top 40 hits played on your clear channel radio station. “But I’m not some hipster living in Silverlake going to Spaceland every night!” you say. “ I have no clue about music!! where do I start??” Well, a few suggestions. One like I said, is just to listen to other fanmixes. Back in my day they were around on livejournal, but in this day and age, the majority tend to be on 8tracks. It’s easy to upload and the music streams. (You kids have it good. In MY day, we had to download each song one by one!). If you find a song you like, check out the artist. There’s a good chance they’re on Spotify. Check out the other songs they’ve done. Also Pandora is a good place to find music similar to the artist. Just don’t be afraid to step outside your comfort zone. One of the best parts I’ve found about fanmixes is that people are MUCH more inclined to listen to them and check out new music when they’re about a character/show/pairing they enjoy, as opposed to when you’re being THAT person and insisting to them “oh my god you need to check out THIS band they’re SOOO good”

Aw Yeh! I found a bunch of music it’s super good how do I choose???

Ok, so now you got some music that Ryan Seacreast has never heard of, you’re good to go! My best advice would be this. Mood is more important than literalness. I say this because when I FIRST started making fanmixes, I thought if I did them for a show, I needed to have a song for EVERY single character. This lead to a LOOOOT of stretching and really bloated mixes (I mean REALLY bloated. I once did one for Naruto), and also ment that I had chosen a hard-rock song next to a Bjork song, next to a Mo-Town and so on. Don’t worry so much about if you can’t find a song that works perfectly for a specific character, or a scene. It needs to be more about the mood or what the song is implying. Also, make sure you know what the songs about. Back in the day, Tori Amos songs ran rampant and songs about miscarriage or sexual abuse ended up on what were suppose to be mixes for cutsy-poo pairings all the time.

.Tell me more about being cohesive!!!

Say no more my friend, it’s what I’m here for. Your music for your fanmix should be cohesive Remember what I said earlier about how my earlier fanmixes were not very good because I didn’t have a cohesiveness? Yep. Don’t do this. In theory your entire mix should be able to be on the same Pandora radio station.  (maybe a very heavily tailored Pandora radio station, but still). What helps me in being cohesive is figuring out what music is gonna work best. Is this a cute upbeat character? A scary monster of a villain? A tragic doomed pairing? If you can start to find music that works for these things, you’re off to a good start!

 I got a bunch of songs, they all work great and they all kinda fit together!!!!

Hooray! Now you got 8 or more songs that are cool and good and you wanna upload them! Now what? For me, I like to think of fanmixes like a color wheel. Blue doesn’t go RIGHT after red, you need to put some purple in there first. Make sure your mix flows to avoid a lack of cohesiveness. Also think of your mix a bit like a musical. Have an ‘opening’ song. Make it a strong one that grabs the audience and makes them certain that they’re gonna want to listen to your entire mix. I also like to think of the final songs like an ending credit song. (so if you have a song you’re worried is gonna turn off people for being too on the nose, this is a good place to put it.)

 That’s my best advice for fanmixes! As I said, that’s simply what I enjoy and what works for me. But if you have any questions, or wanna add your own experiences and imput, feel free to add on!  

My own fanmixes (and a few regular old mixes) can be found here if you wanna have a laugh at my own cockiness. 

she hated him [listen here]

i. just the girl - the click five // i. accidentally in love - counting crows // iii. i melt with you - modern english // iv. in my veins - andrew belle // v. total eclipse of the heart - bonnie tyler // vi. hallelujah - jeff buckley // vii. a thousand years - christina perri // viii. summer nights - glee cast // ix. welcome home - radical face // x. i will follow you into the dark - death cab for cutie


i. Centuries; Fall Out Boy // ii. Monster; Imagine Dragons // iii. No Light, No Light; Florence + The Machine // iv. I Can’t Decide; Scissor Sisters // v. My songs know what you did in the Dark (Light Em Up); Fall Out Boy // vi. Gold; Imagine Dragons // vii. I Will Never Die; Delta Rae // viii. I Don’t Care; Fall Out Boy // ix. Everybody wants to Rule the World; Lorde

[L I S T E N]

[A R T  C R E D I T]


Much Ado About SHIELDThe Playlist

When high school seniors and bitter rivals Leopold Fitz and Jemma Simmons sign up for the SHIELD Academy drama league production of William Shakespeare’s Much Ado About Nothing, they certainly were not expecting this… Bickering rivals, denied crushes and devious scheming are all present in Much Ado About SHIELD…

More information about the other aspects of the gift

From silfp​ and etoilesdeglace​ for mrsdecaestecker​ and otherpartyfavors​ as part of the Fitzsimmons Better Together Exchange. We loved working with this prompt and we hope you enjoy it just as much as we enjoyed making it!

Don’t Mess With Me // A Felix McScouty Fanmix

// 01. Mercenary - Panic! at the Disco // 02. Don’t Mess With Me - Temposhark // 03. American Trash - Innerpartysystem // 04. How Bad Can I Be? - Ed Helms // 05. Na Na Na - My Chemical Romance // 06. Gives You Hell - The All-American Rejects // 07. Wild Soul - Cristina Scarlet // 08. Aha! - Penatonix // 09. Don’t Stop - Innerpartysystem // 10. You’re Gonna Go Far, Kid - The Offspring // 11. Move - Thousand Foot Krutch // 12. Faint - Linkin Park // 13. Bad Blood - Creature Feature // 14. I Don’t Care - Fall Out Boy // 15. Flawed Design - Stabilo // 16. Headstrong - Trapt // Bonus: I’m Sexy and I Know It - LMFAO //

art by electricgale