edit: martin st louis

Jonathan Toews taught me to be a leader and always stand up for your team

Corey Crawford taught me never to give up on your dream no matter how long it takes to get there

Bobby Ryan taught me that no matter how bad your home life is you can still become a star

Tim Thomas taught me it doesn’t matter how old you are, you can become the greatest

Martin St. Louis taught me it doesn’t matter how tall you are

Marian Hossa taught me dreams do come true

Sidney Crosby taught me to always work hard

Daniel Carcillo taught me to be brave against any opponent

Late last month, during a meeting of the St. Louis Board of Aldermen, a shoving match broke out among members of the public — some of them off-duty police officers.

The cause of the tension was a proposal to create a new civilian oversight authority for the police. Advocates of police reform like civilian oversight, but police officers say the boards are often politicized and unfair to them.

The concept of civilian police oversight isn’t new. In 1965, New York Mayor John Lindsay proposed including civilians on a review board as a way to address complaints from minority groups about police misconduct. But the move backfired; the police union and conservatives such as William F. Buckley rallied against civilian oversight, and voters later defeated the idea in a city-wide vote, returning the the board to police only. It took more than two decades for civilian oversight of police to be restored in New York.

The idea fared better in other cities. In Kansas City, Mo., the Office of Community Complaints was the brainchild of a personal injury lawyer named Sid Willens. He says his eyes were opened to the problem of police accountability in 1965, when he tried to get justice for a client who’d been badly beaten while handcuffed. Willens says the police department’s internal investigation simply confirmed the officer’s version of what happened. “It’s like having the fox guard the chicken house,” Willens says.

Police Are Learning To Accept Civilian Oversight, But Distrust Lingers

Photo caption: Late last month, a scuffle cut short a St. Louis Board of Aldermen meeting where a committee was to discuss a proposed civilian review board for the city’s police force. Photo credit: Robert Cohen/Courtesy of St. Louis Post-Dispatch