Request: Hello love! Hope you’re having an awesome day :) I was wondering if you could do an imagine where the reader is like a total badass and has been the only lost girl for a long time and her and Peter are like “a thing” but haven’t really labeled themselves, then suddenly Wendy appears and Peter starts to neglect the reader for her and then the reader makes Peter decide between her or Wendy? Xx
Pairing: Reader × Peter Pan × Wendy Darling
You drew the bow back and aimed the arrow straight at the head of the wild boar. Felix always told you to aim for the head so the meat isn’t damaged and the animal dies instantly.
You released and smiled proudly when the boar instantly dropped.
You started skinning the boar with the pocket knife that Peter gave you a while ago. You felt a hand on your shoulder, “Nice kill, Y/N.”
You turned your head and smiled when you saw Peter admiring the boar.
“Thank you” you said as Peter squat down next to you and started helping you.
The day ended with Peter and you making out against a tree. Peter pulled away and started kissing your neck.
You wrapped your arms around his neck and moaned softly.
Peter stopped and backed away quickly, “Someone’s on the island.”
Peter could always feel when someone either came on the island or left the island.
You quickly grabbed the sack full of the boar meat and followed Pan to the beach where people usually landed.
When you arrived there was a girl, wandering around, looking lost. She was wearing a white dress and had blonde hair.
“W-who are you??” She asked.
Peter held his hands up and started walking towards the girl, “I’m Peter, Peter Pan.”
You secretly hoped that she was temporary. You were the only girl on the island and you liked it that way. Plus, she was very pretty which made you nervous that Peter would take an interest into her.
Peter and you definitely acted like a couple but didn’t really put a label on it.
“Y/N, will you please bring the meat to the boys. I’m going to show our new friend Wendy around.” Peter said to you.
You looked from Peter to Wendy, a disapproving look on your face. “Are you sure about this?” You asked Peter.
He nodded and put his hand on your cheek and gave you a quick kiss, “Don’t be worried” he stated.
You smiled and walked back to the campsite with the sack of meat.
Peter never came back for dinner. He wasn’t even there when you fell asleep in his bed. When you first came on the island Peter gave you a tour but it certainly didn’t last this long.
You woke up with Peter’s arm around your waist and his head rested on your shoulder. You smiled and laid on your side and gave Pan a soft kiss.
His eyes fluttered open and smile spread across his face, “Good morning my lovely lost girl.”
You smiled and wrapped your arms around him and bit your lip, “So, what’s Wendy like?”
“Well, she’s sweet and seems very innocent and scared.” He said looking up at the ceiling.
You rolled your eyes and got out of bed and started putting your clothes back on. “Where are you going babe?” Peter asked sitting up in bed.
“I’m gonna go start target practice with the lost boys.” You said putting your boots on.
Peter got up and wrapped his arms around your waist and kissed your forehead, “You alright darling?”
You smiled and nodded, “Of course.” You leaned up and gave him a quick kiss on the lips and left the tree house.
You had a day full of teaching the lost boys how to throw knives, how to hunt and you did a little cleaning up.
Peter hasn’t been around all day, neither was Wendy so you knew that they had to be together.
You didn’t want to feel jealous or clingy because you two weren’t “together” but you were a girl, of course you would feel those emotions.
Peter and Wendy came back to the camp just in time for dinner. You watched Peter give Wendy some,food,and then he sat down right next to her and began eating.
You got up angrily and walked to Peter’s tree house and decided to wait on his bed to confront him.
Peter came up several hours later, “Y/N, I’ve been looking for you all over! You had me worried” Peter said sitting next to you taking your hand in his.
You pulled away and stood up, “I’m just going to be straight up with you. Do you have a thing for Wendy?” You asked staring straight at him.
Peter frowned, “What??”
“Don’t play stupid with me Pan, you’ve been ditching me and the lost boys for her.”
Peter smirked and stood up, “Are you jealous?”
You rolled your eyes, “Screw off Peter. Why would I be jealous of a girl like that when I’m ten times better?” You said crossing your arms.
Peter came closer to you and grabbed your face, “I don’t know why but I know you are darling.”
You pushed Peter away, tears filling your eyes, “Choose Pan.”
Peter frowned over you calling him Pan, you never have called him that.
“Choose what Y/N?” Peter asked with a frown.
“Choose between me and Wendy. You obviously feel something for her. How could you not? She’s pretty, innocent and afraid. Just how you liked me when I first came on the island.”
“You’re being ridiculous Y/N” Peter said backing up.
Tears started running down your face, “Oh yeah? Is that why you’re leaving to go to see Wendy?”
Peter breathed out and looked at the door then you, “ Y/N..”
You wiped your eyes and walked past Peter, “I’ll go” you said lowering down onto the ladder.
You looked up at Peter, “Hope you’re happy.”
You climbed down the ladder and turned your back on the tree house and the thing you loved the most.