Now that the anon mentions barbara. I feel like she's the only girl we have seen so kind of intimate interaction and public display. Not only the pictures from the concert but her comforting a crying Niall with Liam and his mom. And he actually taking her to spent New Years with him.
also…..😭 rmr their golf date….and he was helping her swing…..and when she wore his jacket at a restaurant…..and yes when she was comforting him during the very last JLS concert….rip…..