Summary: Dean is forced to come clean about his time with Cassie, and you take revenge in your own petty way (minimal episode plot)
Words: 500+ (drabble)
Dean x Reader, Sam x Jess, Dean x Cassie, OMC x Reader
Warnings: infidelity, implied smut
A/N: this is part of my ‘Jess never died’ rewrite, find the masterpost here
There was a tense silence when the four of you met up in a bar after Sam and Dean had finished a hunt in Missouri.
You looked at Sam across the booth, confused, but he just motioned to Dean to explain.
“So?” you prompted, already irritated, “What’s the deal?”
“I, uh,” he cleared his throat, “The hunt, the victim was my, uh- my ex’s father.”
“Right,” you nodded, following along.
Dean looked at Sam, pleading in his eyes, and you frowned at him.
“Fucking spit it out, Dean.”
“I slept with her,” he blurted, and Sam and Jess froze in their seats.