Pairing: Dean x Winchester Sister!Reader, Sam x Winchester
Sister!Reader, John x daughter!reader
Warnings: Abandonment, drugging, kidnapping, abuse, car
Word Count: 4721
A/N: This was written for Kas’ 2.5k Dialogue Prompt
Challenge @kas-not-cas My prompt was “You have no idea who I am, do you?”. This takes
place about mid season 5, not that it really matters. That is the time frame
that fits the ages I’m working with and it was before the bunker. This isn’t the
whole story I promise. I meant for this to be a one-shot but it got really
long, like this is the longest one-shot I’ve written, and I’m tired from
cleaning all day so I thought this was a good place to stop. The second part
will probably be really short but it will wrap things up and will be out tomorrow. That being said, I am
really proud of this one so tell me what you think feedback is always welcomed
and appreciated.Also un-beta-ed and unedited because I’m tired af so all mistakes are mine and I apologize in advance.
Summary: You are John’s youngest and Sam and Dean’s little
sister. You were basically left in their laps by your mother as an infant. One
day, when your five years old, you are kidnapped on Dean’s watch. Ten years
later you run into Dean in a coincidental accident. What happens when he
^ pretend thats young Dean
^ I know that’s JJ but lets pretend this is the relationship that Dean and his little sister have.
^When the part comes and you will know it. Imagine this but obviously not as romantic because that would be weird, especially considering the events taking place at that moment.
Did anyone take note of this? He’s talking about Toni Bevell, but more to the point: Dean’s seen Frozen. Do you know how happy this makes me? It’s not just Dory. Just how many recent Disney movies have you seen, Dean? Please tell me you’ve watched Cars.
A/N: Okay so I lied, this isn’t a short part 2. I got
carried away and completely scraped my outlined ending so I could stretch this
and make more parts. Part 1 has gotten 122 notes in just under 24 hours which
is the most I have ever gotten on a story and in such a short time. Thanks for
all the kind words about part 1 and hope you enjoy part 2. I don’t know when a
part 3 will be out since I still have to outline it but expect it sometime in
the future. The continuation of this story is all thanks to you guys so give
yourselves a round of applause as you have given me more work to do lol. Just
kidding I actually really like this series myself and I look forward to
Summary: The police now believe Dean about your kidnapping,
but since you have crossed state lines how do they deal with the situation of
your “parents”? You can’t really focus too much on your parents as you can’t get
the thoughts of Dean out of your head. Why was everything about this man so
familiar? One thing is for sure nothing is making sense, but then again, isn’t it?
You guys have the same eyes…. what else could be shared?
(Sorry this summary is shit. My head just wants to spoil
everything, but I have to hold back and this is that product.)
***Italics are flashbacks/memories***
^ Just imagine in the hospital with a cast on one leg and hair a little longer.
^ Ok but picture this but with only the top half of his body laying down on the side of your hospital bed, next to you
It’s been a long day, little Y/N was already asleep when Sam buckled her into her car seat. “Buggy already asleep?” Dean asks as the two of them get into the car. Sam sits in the back with you, to keep you company amongst a few other reasons.
“Yeah.” Sam replies as he protectively wraps his arm around your small frame. You promptly lean your head against his chest. A few miles away from the bunker a car t-bones the door of the impala, causing Dean to loose traction as well as control of his car.
“You two okay?” Dean asks when the impala comes to a stop.
“I’m a bit banged up, otherwise okay. It’s (nickname) I’m worried about, she’s in rough shape Dean.” Sam answers worriedly. The eldest Winchester starts mentally chewing out the person that wrecked his car as well as hurt his five year old sister.
After the paramedics arrive everything is a bit of a blur, but time seems to stop when a nurse tells the brothers that their little sister is in critical condition as well as in a coma.
A day later, Cas shows up and does all he can to help you- which isn’t much. “I’m sorry I can’t do more.” He says sadly.
“It’s okay Cas, at least she’s not in critical condition anymore.” Dean answers as he gently rubs his thumb over your small knuckles.
It’s been three weeks and you show no sign of waking up. “I’m going to Bobby’s to fix up baby. Call me if something happens.” Dean says standing up, and as he grabs the keys. The car that is currently in use is one of the spare cars from the garage of the bunker.
“You know I will.” Sam answers as Dean leaves. He then sighs and moves your hair out of your face. “Guess it’s just me and you kiddo.” As expected you don’t make any form of response.
🐝 🐝 🐝 🐝 🐝
You were back where you started again. You sit on the ground and start to cry- you just want to go home but you can’t. Someone places a gentle hand on your shoulder. “Don’t cry cupcake; if you cry you’re going to make me cry.” Someone says. You look up and see a person with golden eyes and golden hair standing over you. His presence is comforting and for some reason he reminds you of Cas.
“Who are you?” You sniffle as the golden haired man sits down next to you.
“I’m a friend, and I want to help you.” The man then pulls out a lollipop out of nowhere. Before he unwraps it he offers it to you. “Want a piece?”
“Sammy says I shouldn’t take candy from strangers.” You softly answer. The man chuckles.
“I don’t blame the moose for that one- but I assure you, I’m not a stranger. I’m Gabriel, or Gabe if you prefer…” The golden eyed archangel notices how you still don’t trust him. So he decides to change tactics. “Your brothers and Cas sent me. They’re worried about you.” You wipe your runny nose with the back of your hand.
“I miss them and I wanna go home.” You look at Gabriel with watery eyes.
“Hey, it’s okay. I’ll get you home, I promise.”
“Pinkie promise?” You ask holding up your small pinkie. The golden eyed angel smiles as he wraps his pinkie around yours.
🐝 🐝 🐝 🐝 🐝
I turn on Y/N’s favorite Disney movie, praying for a miracle. Another reason why I turn on the movie is to get the song You Are My Sunshine out of my head. I look at the screen and smile to myself. The part that is playing is one of my sister’s all time favorite parts. “I can’t quote your favorite part of (favorite Disney movie) by myself Princess.” I say. The only response I get from Y/N is the beeping of her heart monitor.
Hours go by, different nurses stop by just doing their rounds. Good news is, is that Y/N’s condition is slowly improving, but she’s still in a coma. What I wouldn’t give to hear Y/N’s laugh, or see her beautiful (eye color) eyes right now. I gently squeeze my little sister’s hand. It’s extremely soft- insomuch I nearly miss it, but Y/N just squeezed my hand in return. I fish my phone out of my pocket and call my brother. “What’s happening Sammy?” Dean asks when he picks up.
“Y/N just squeezed my hand.” I reply.
“She squeezed your hand?”
“It was an incredibly soft squeeze, I mean it was so soft in I nearly missed it.”
“A squeeze is a squeeze…hey Sammy I need to go. Mind keeping me posted?”
“Of course. Talk to you later.”
“Later.” With that Dean hangs up. That was one of the quickest conversations that I’ve had with my brother- I’m also confused on what he meant by having to go. He more then likely wanted to get back to fixing his car or he had to use the restroom, it’s one of those two. 🐝 🐝 🐝 🐝 🐝
Gabe has kept his promise on helping you get home, but there hasn’t been any luck on actually getting you back to your brothers. “I’m never getting home.” You sniffle.
“Come on don’t talk like that. It might take a little bit but you’ll get home.” Gabe replies. “We’ll try again later, okay Cookie?” You simply nod in response.
“Why do you keep calling me food?” You randomly ask, you also tilt your head slightly in confusion. Causing Gabe to softly chuckle to himself.
“I’m not exactly calling you food- I’m calling you sugary snacks.” Your friend says as he pops a lollipop in his mouth. “Besides it wouldn’t be fair if I left you out of the mix- I call your brothers all sorts of nicknames.” You let out a small giggle in response. Your friend then offers you a lollipop and this time you accept the candy mainly because you know Gabriel would never hurt you. He’s almost as protective of you as your brothers and Cas.
After awhile Gabe asks if you’re ready to try again to get you home. Surprisingly you shake your head. “Thought you wanted to go home though.” Gabe comments right when you yawn and rub your eyes. “Oh…” you fall asleep against him. Gabe doesn’t let you sleep long though, and he gave you no explanation why he didn’t want you to sleep at the moment.
🐝 🐝 🐝 🐝 🐝
Normally Dean and I switch off with who stays with Y/N at the hospital- but I haven’t seen my brother since this morning. So I have a feeling that’s not going to be happening tonight. Cas pops by with an angel I thought was dead. “I thought you were dead Gabe.” I comment.
“That wasn’t really my thing.” The archangel replies as he places two fingers on my little sister’s forehead using his grace to heal her. He mutters a few things under his breath. When he removes his fingers he smiles. “She’ll be okay and waking up soon.”
“Thank you Gabe.”
“You’re welcome- besides I like Y/N.” With that the archangel pops off. Leaving me to wonder about what he meant by that.
🐝 🐝 🐝 🐝 🐝
-no one POV-
When you open your eyes, Sam doesn’t hesitate to call a nurse. About half an hour later you’re moved from ICU to a regular hospital room. “Sammy where’s De?” Little Y/N asks her (eye color) eyes have a bit of worry and fear in them.
“Want to talk to him?” Sam replies pulling out his phone. You nod as Sam dials his brother’s number.
“Hey Sammy, any changes?” Dean asks when he answers the phone.
“Yeah, Buggy’s going to be okay.” Sam answers looking at you, you smile a little bit in reply. “Also someone wants to talk to you.”
“Oh really who?”
“If I told you it would ruin the surprise.” Sam says before passing you the phone “Say hello.” Your brother gently encourages.
🐝 🐝 🐝 🐝 🐝
I start to think that Sam hung up on me… but suddenly there I hear a voice on the other line that I haven’t heard in weeks. “Hello?” The person on the other end is my baby sister.
“Hey Baby bug.” I answer standing up and walking away from baby. I’m also trying not to cry at the moment.
“De!” She happily squeaks. I chuckle to myself.
“Whatcha doing kiddo?”
“Sammy put in a movie for me.”
“Did he now, what one is it?”
“(Favorite Disney movie.)” A smile forms on my face.
“Did I miss your favorite part?”
“That’s okay… hey Buggy could you do me a favor, and give the phone back to Sammy?”
“Otay… love you De.”
“Love you too (Nickname).”
🐝 🐝 🐝 🐝 🐝
-No one’s POV-
Once Y/N is released from the hospital she gets all sorts of confused when she doesn’t see the impala. “That not De’s car.” You say.
“Don’t remind me.” Dean replies, as he climbs into the driver’s seat leaving Sam to help you with your car seat. Before San can sit in the passenger seat you give him the puppy dog eyes asking him to sit in the back with you. You would’ve done it to Dean but he was in the driver’s seat before you could even ask him.
“Not today squirt… besides, you’ve got Cas to keep you company.” Sam says when he’s done buckling you in and when he sees the trenchcoat wearing angel sitting next to you.
On the way back to the bunker you fall asleep against Cas- car rides always puts you to sleep. The angel becomes confused on why he is suddenly being used as a pillow. “Is this normal?” Cas asks gesturing towards you.
“Nine times out of ten yes- but mind keeping an eye on her? Rather not take her back to the hospital because she fell back into a coma.” Sam answers.
“She’s just asleep.” Cas replies as he removes his fingers from your forehead. “She’ll be fine.”
For the first few weeks of you being back home at the bunker, your brothers take turns of keeping an eye on you throughout the night- just to be sure you don’t fall back into a coma.
You’ve given both of your brothers a fair share of heart attacks- mainly because when you get nightmares you always go to one of your brother’s rooms… and you never really go to the brother who is keeping an eye on you that night.
🐝 🐝 🐝 🐝 🐝
It’s Dean’s turn to keep an eye on you- and the hinges on his door softly squeak open waking him up slightly. He tiredly reaches for the gun under his pillow before turning to see who opened the door- it’s just you and your stuffed animal friend. “Why are you still awake kiddo?” Dean asks with a yawn.
“Scary dream.” You reply softly, you then say you stayed with Sam the last time you had a nightmare. Dean disguises a chuckle as a yawn, before making room for you. You then crawl under the covers and snuggle next to your brother absorbing his warmth.
“Night munchkin.” Dean says as he kisses the crown of your head- yeah you’re going to be just fine. Baby on the other hand isn’t going to be roadworthy any time soon… much to Dean’s annoyance. Even though he’ll never admit it, he would rather have his baby destroyed, but his family is alive; than the the other way around… a car can always be rebuilt; however the pain of losing someone that you love is like a wound that never wants to close… a wound that always finds away how to open after one is positive that it’s healed.
Yes, the car where you carved your initials in when you were kids.
The car you rebuilt from basically the ground up after nearly dying.
The car you drive across the country in.
The car you call ‘baby’.
The car your brother spent months driving around after thinking you died. The car you grew up in.
So say it again… It’s just a car. But it’s so much more to you,
Part 1 Warnings: Angst, Mentions of past torture Summary: Sam and Dean’s younger sister caught Mary working with the BMoL and left to protect the Colt and her family. How will the Winchesters and Cas react when they see that she’s gone? Word Count: 1946 (It’s a little longer than the first part) Tags are below the cut. Let me know if you want to be added or removed from the list.
Cas walked to the library after stopping in front of Y/N’s door. She asked to be left alone so Cas respected that. He saw Sam and Dean sitting at one of the tables with drinks in their hands. “Hey, Cas.” Dean called. “Where’s Y/N?” “Her room.” He answered. “She said she wanted to be left alone.” Sam looked at the angel. “Did something happen on the way back?” “No.” Castiel lied. “She said she was tired.” “I guess we’ll see her in the morning.” Dean said. Moments later Mary walked in and sat down next to Dean. She looked around. “Where’s Y/N?” “She went to bed.” Sam informed her. “Cas said she was tired.” “Oh.” Mary whispered. “I was going to talk to her.” “You’ll have to wait until morning.” Sam laughed. “She sleeps like a rock.” Dean added. About an hour later they went their separate ways and headed to bed. The next morning Dean walked down to his sister’s room to get her up for breakfast. He knocked on the door and didn’t hear a response. He opened the door and walked in to see her bed empty. He looked around and noticed the dresser drawers were mostly empty and her weapons bag was missing from the closet. He was about to yell for Sam when he saw folded pieces of paper resting on the pillow. There was one for him, Sam, Cas, and Mary. He grabbed his letter and eased onto the edge of the bed.