I read bad reviews about this (it’s not even officially released yet!) and expected to hate it. But I ordered anyway because I love the mascara. Turns out - I LOVE this, too. Some people said it’s dry, but I think if you’re used to using a cream/gel liner, this won’t be much different for you. Staying power is good, color is a deep, rich black, and in my opinion it’s pretty creamy. I give it a thumbs up for sure. #benefit #theyrerealliner #pushupliner #beauty #beautyhaul #makeup #creamliner #gelliner #theyrereal