Oh! I haven’t seen Supernatural since season 5, I think… But here we go ;)

bake cupcakes for: Bobby
trust with the keys to my car: Bobby
put thumbtacks on the chair thereof:
have a crush on:
 Dean, Cas and Crowley…
pack up and leave if they moved next door: Oh god: The Winchesters. Not ready for that kind of craziness in my life
vote for President:
 Bobby and Crowley? Oh yeah
pick as my partner in a buddy movie:
 Crowley… Or Gabriel
pair up:
 Dean and Cas tbh
vote off the island and into the volcano:
 Soulless Sam
wheedle into fixing my MP3 player: