Winchesters in Riverdale (Part Two)
After a hunt gone wrong, Y/N Winchester, the 17 year old half-sister of Sam and Dean Winchester, her older brothers, and Castiel are transported to Riverdale, a town in a different universe. While Sam, Dean, and Castiel attempt to find a way back home, Y/N struggles to fit in in community of Riverdale. In a universe with no monsters to worry about, there’s so many questions that need answering.
Can she ever try to be normal after hunting for all of her life? Who’s the good-looking, mystical teen with the beanie who’s always at that diner? And will anyone discover that secret she’s been hiding for the last year and a half?
“What do you mean I have to go to school?” you asked in disbelief as Dean dumped a bunch of school supplies on your motel bed along with a black backpack.
He sighed and sat down in the long chair across the room.
“People’ll get suspicious if there’s a random teen hanging around us during school hours. So unless you wanna be holed up in the motel for God knows how long, you’re going to school.”
You were about to protest when Sam cut you off.
“It’s just for a little bit, Y/N,” he said in an attempt to placate you. “Until we find a way to get outta here.”
You sighed defeatedly.
“Fine.” you said quietly as you sat back against the headboard of the bed, crossing your arms.
Everyone was silent for a moment before Dean spoke again.
“Oh, and you’re with the sophomores. All the junior classes were full.” he said.
Your mouth dropped open.
“Are you serious?!” you exclaimed.
“We signed you up for a mythology class though! You like mythology. That class has kids from all different grades in it.” Sam said.
You glared at him.
“Fine. Just—fine. Whatever.” you mumbled.
Dean rose his eyebrows at your tone.
“You know, I don’t know what’s going on with you. You’ve had a lot more chutzpah since you came back.”
“Dean.” Sam warned.
You looked down. You didn’t want to talk about this now.
“No, I’m serious, Sam,” Dean continued. “She disappears without a trace and then magically returns after a year. Now, she says it was because she had to take a break after Kevin—“
“Dean!” Sam exclaimed again and you winced at the mention of your dead boyfriend.
Dean was quiet as he watched you fiddling with your jacket sleeve, trying not to cry.
“I—Y/N, I’m sorry.” Dean sighed.
“It’s fine.” you said quietly.
“I just—we were just worried. You know that. We didn’t hear from you for a year. We thought you might’ve been dead. You just… left.”
You nodded slowly.
“No, I know.” you mumbled.
Everyone was silent again.
“Well, um, I’m gonna get some dinner for us,” Dean said as he got up. “Does, uh, anyone have any preferences?”
Everyone shook their head.
“Right,” he said. “Cas, come with me?”
Castiel nodded but not before walking over to you, handing you notebooks you didn’t even know he had in his hand. You looked up at him.
“I, uh, got you these in different colors. I didn’t know which one was your favorite.” he said.
You smiled softly.
“Thank you, Cas. I appreciate it.”
Castiel nodded before he walked out of the motel with Dean, leaving you with just Sam.
It was silent before Sam spoke again.
“Do you want to talk about it?” he asked quietly.
You froze and looked up at him.
Your brother looked at you with his puppy dog eyes.
“You’re always thinking about the same thing. Ever since you came back. I can see it in your eyes. After everything I’ve gone through, I wish I would’ve accepted some help from—”
“Please stop.” you pleaded.
Sam looked at you.
“Y/N?” he asked gently.
You swallowed the lump in your throat.
“Why are you and Dean so adamant on finding out where I was?” you asked, anger tinting your voice.
“Because Y/N, we can see it’s eating at you. You want to tell someone what happened.” he said softly.
You got up, glaring at your brother.
“No, I don’t! I want you guys to leave me alone! Okay?! That was the deal. I come back and you guys ask no questions. So stop interrogating me!” you nearly yelled.
Sam looked down, hurt and you felt tears well up in your eyes, guilt filling you. You knew he was only trying to help.
“I-I’m going out. I’ll be back later. Tell Dean I’m at that diner or something. I don’t care.” you said as you walked towards the door.
“Wait, Y/N.” Sam began as he got up.
“Sam,” you warned, looking back at your brother.
He stopped, looking at you with concern.
“Don’t.” you said and with that you stepped out of the motel, closing the door behind you.
The warm spring air from earlier had cooled down, making you pull your jacket closer to you. The sun was starting to set, giving off a beautiful orange glare. As you walked down the street from the motel, kicking at rocks, you remembered the last day you had seen Kevin.
“Hey guys.” Kevin said as he stepped out from behind Chuck.
Your and your brothers eyes widened.
“Kevin?” you whispered.
You let out a breathless laugh and rushed over to him, throwing your arms around him. He hugged you back tightly and it was then you realized he wasn’t cold like a ghost, but he was… warm? You pulled away from his, holding what you thought was your long dead boyfriend by the shoulders.
“H-How are you—”
“You never got a chance to say goodbye, did you?” Chuck said from next to you.
You shook your head.
“No.” you whispered.
Chuck smiled at you.
“Well, now you do. I’m giving you one last day together. 24 hours starting now. Then he goes to Heaven. I’ll see you later.” he said and with that, disappeared.
You turned back to Kevin who was beaming at you.
“So… what do you want to do?” he asked.
You tried to keep your tears at bay as you walked down the street, shoving your hands in your pockets. Yes, you and Kevin dated. You met him when you were thirteen and started dating him a little after you had turned fourteen. You had tried to keep it a secret from Sam, Dean, and Castiel but they found out within a couple months. Sam was worried (when was he not?) for the both of you, Castiel was indifferent to the situation, and Dean had tried to break you apart, claiming you weren’t allowed to date anyone until you were married.
“But I’m not ever getting married, Dean!”
You cracked a smile as you remembered your eldest brother’s reaction to your relationship. Despite his disgust towards you guys kissing and all, you managed to catch him smirking at the two of you holding hands at one point (though he vehemently denied it and then sent you to do research for two weeks.)
However, your smile faded as you remembered the day, that horrible day when you found Kevin on the ground in the bunker with his eyes burned out. Dean was apologizing to you over and over again but you didn’t even hear him. You were in such a shock, you couldn’t cry. You could barely even breathe. It was the worst day of your life.
You shook your head again, trying to rid yourself of the memories. You thought you could move on from Kevin’s death after Chuck had granted you one day with him. But it only spiraled out of control from there.
A/N: Before I wrote this fic, I actually did write a Kevin x OC story, but never posted it. I’m kinda combining it with this one, and I like how it’s turning out so far! Hope you guys are liking it too!
@lydixstiles @jughead-from-riverdale @pinkhappypanda @iamthegoatmaster @subsi4123 @deanskitten @latenightbooknerd @lostinpercyseyes @captainelsaeverdeen @itsjaynebird @allineedisconnor @juggie-jones-iii @superoriginalteenwolf @sastielstan @1amluke @satanwithstardust @johnmurphys-sass @theselfishllama @katshrev @juggiesjuliet @betty-coopers-number-one-stan @imperfectanatomy @casismyguardianangel @irrajj @babearchie @fangites @apocalypticangell @sparklingriverdale @jvghead-jones-iii @onceuponagladerhead @isabellaskyliner @vodkaluh @tegan-eva @murderyoursoul @regenpony @xbobaaa @farmfreshcoldsprouts @hellolittlebigstudent @audreyxhorne @faithmichaluk @thebloodyshuckface @castawayalicia @lost-in-wonderland-x @holoqraphik @soulception @jughead-archie-imagines @juggys-betty @twizzlersnizzler @riverdale–trash @barbarachern @juggiejunkie @likesiriusly @thatsavagehufflepuff @multi-madison @frobert20 @the-local-dreamer-star @stephyra17 @reginaphlanageadams @river-vixns @genderabused @wetsknn
Winchesters in Riverdale Taglist
@famchester @sardonic-jug @prettylies-uglyface @mummastace @saltygay-bean @miraculousrain @emmalynnhockey @polaroidgilmores @thoughtfulfandomtrash @nan-the-lemon @diyoceanbeachup22 @gingerfangirlthefeels @yasminepc @thatcrazyfangirlmaze @acambridge @baasooreexiiaa @disappointeddinosaur @lena-lightwood @pathetic-pisces @s-kellington @seninjakitey @cloudy-1-nights @badwolfgirlatbakerst @lcil123 @seiteixnalaicos @enthusiasmisdepressing @music-hoeee @alice-schlipalius @im-a-hufflepuff-what-can-i-say @b0byyy @therealwatermelon @princess-sweatpants @suitelifeofjughead @lxrrystylinsonfucking69 @milkshakejones @daehguj @the-chick-with-the-best-fandom @strxngerluna @belbow @writers-coffee @wayward-mutant @sastielstan @unicornqueen05 @nessy-bearxb @annoyingsibling @team-jessdeservesbetter @jealousbitxh @forsythependletonjonestheiii @rabid-creatures @bitch-ivyxx @theriverdaledaleash @aconfusedidentity