We’ve got a problem. The manifest, Jack, the census, the names of everyone who survived, all 46 of us. I interviewed everyone. Here, at the beach, got their names. One them, one of them isn’t — Jack! One of them isn’t in the manifest. He wasn’t on the plane.
This scene breaks my heart. Its the moment we all realised that someone has to tell her he didn’t make it. Look at how much hope she has in her eyes. so excited to see him again. searching the crowd for the one person she has been worrying about since the moment he left. so unaware of his fate. Its so bitter sweet because she looks so beautiful and happy but we all know what’s to come. That horrible news we don’t want her to ever find out. Wanting her to stay in the bliss of this moment filled with so much hope, excitement and love. Oh Claire.