carson ships it

5

Ships I Ship: Cinderella Story couples

4

Jay & Evie protecting each other

Imagine an au where Ben falls for Jay instead by accident.

At first they think it’s worked on Mal until Did I Mention and he starts to spell Jay’s name instead. Mal is pissed off, Carlos is shitting one, Jay is terrified but weirdly complimented, and Evie is just loving it.

They decide just to try and make it work and all the scenes with Mal and Ben, Jay replaces Mal.

Imagine Jay singing If Only.
Carlos is super pissed bc Jaylos 5ever.
I’m having too much fun with this.

(help from every-morning-just-the-same with this headcanon)