westerngayfairytales replied to your post:

   I think Alex will believe that Maggie doesn’t like VDay, but she’ll think Maggie will like what she makes for her. You know, like “ok, you don’t like VDay, but Imma cook you dinner and light some candles and put on your playlist, what’s not to like?” But she’ll be wrong :|    

This is so cute and sad and it makes me go!!!! My poor atelophobic baby gay Alex wanting to go all out and do something perfect for Maggie, and then getting disappointed when she realizes that Maggie meant exactly what she said about Valentine’s. And then Maggie “Extra-est Girlfriend To Ever Extra” Sawyer rents out an entire ballroom on her ($35k median) cop salary because that’s how much Alex means to her and if it means making Alex happy she’ll do anything 😭😭😭