Marlene has made it clear that A wont be “officially” revealed until season 6.
She did say however that we could get a big clue as to who they are, which got me thinking.
As we know, A has Tippi. Tippi is a Grey Macaw, a type of parrot, known for their outstanding ability to mimic and repeat phrases. (We know this firsthand because Tippi revealed that phone number to Spencer).
What if our big clue in the finale is revealed by Tippi? Perhaps she mimics A’s voice, or repeats a phrase that A has said, ultimately and quietly revealing their identity?
This episode was a DEAD END! There were LOOPHOLES. Also, there was LACK OF LOGIC as usual. It basically gave NO ANSWERS, butjust MORE QUESTIONS…
It didn’t clarify anything and made the things even worse about the Big A Reveal.
So let’s summarize what happened in the last night’s episode, in the same time I analyze the characters in order to prime top suspects. There is actually not a single suspect, though.
Lesli Stone turned out to be the surprise witness. So now we know why this random new character was added to the show: To ruin the 5 liars.
Ezra Fitz at first seemed hesitant about Aria’s idea of taking Mike to his cabin. He then agreed to do it. He and Caleb had different opinions on what Mike should do. If he and Caleb weren’t under the arrow rain, when Mike ran into the Big A, I would say that Ezra was trying to save Mike from telling the truth just because he was the Big A but now it was because he respected Aria’s decision.
Ella Montgomery also seemed avoidant like she didn’t want to help out Alison and Hanna. After she convinced her student to talk to Spencer and Emily, I changed my opinion about her.
Toby Cavanaugh finally came back to his senses. Tanner left him out of what’s really going on because she knew that Spencer, Emily and Aria were also gonna be arrested if Alison had found guilty.
Andrew Campbell seems suspicious and sketchy more than ever. He seems to envy Ezra. There’s a cut on his hand which Aria never paid attention or thought of asking about. He also told Aria that he was the Scout Pathfinder just after he didn’t pick up Aria’s call the night before when Mike was tied up by Big A and rescued by Ezra and Caleb. We also know that Aria told Andrew about Ezra taking Mike to his cabin.
WHO MIGHT BE THE BIG A IF BASING IT ON THE LAST NIGHT’S EPISODE?
Lesli Stone: I read some people say that Lesli might have been at the Radley when Mona was there. I remember seeing a pic of a girl who looks like her posted on “pll theories”.Whether she was at the Radley before or not, she was just introduced to us in season 5.If even that pic can be proof of Lesli being friends with Mona there, how could it be the proof that she took the game from her? It makes no sense at all. Also, I can’t see a motive there.
Andrew Campbell: Andrew was first introduced to us in Season 3B. In that time, Mona was already out of Radley, she was back to Rosewood High. Andrew had a fling with Spencer in 3B which was how he and Emily knew each other. He also witnessed everything going on between Mona and Spencer. How could he taken the game from Mona if he never was introduced in 3A or was told us that he visited Mona back in the Radley? He then appeared in 4B and gave drugs to Spencer. He then disappeared. He reappeared in 5B and this time, he grew closer to Aria and they are like sort of dating now. Emily was there once again when there was Aria and Andrew interaction. Throughout 5B, Andrew knew Mike was dealing with some stuff and Ezria was falling apart. If Aria had also turned him down like Spencer did before, I’d have understood that he is up to against the liars. Although he didn’t seem to have much of a problem with Mona personally in 3B, he seemed like or pretended to be a Mona hater in 5B. Okay, in 3B, he supported and encouraged Spencer to help her beat Mona but it seemed like he was doing it because he had a crush on Spencer. Back in 5B, he seems to pop out of nowhere, looking like he is up to something or like he is a stalker.If he turns out to be Big A, how are we feel supposed to sorry for him when he doesn’t have Varjack effect on the PLL fandom and audience? If he knew Alison personally before, wouldn’t Alison have warned the girls about his presence in the court while he was sitting next to Aria? There’s no motive that Andrew has to prove that he is Big A.
None of Ezra, Caleb, Mike and Toby might be Big A because Mike was tied up by Big A while Ezra and Caleb were thrown arrows over them, and Toby was making amends with Spencer.
None of the girls might be Big A because now they are all trapped in jail. Also, how could Alison be found guilty of the first degree murder just because she has a certificate in Archery?
Ella Montgomery: She can’t be Big A because she wouldn’t tie her own son up and let her own daughter rot in the prison.
Lieutant Tanner: She seems to hate all the Liars. She seems to hate all of the Liars’ boyfriends. She wasn’t at the police station when Hanna’s texts got deleted at the station. She was just introduced to us in Season 4 though. She has no motive to be Big A. She probably hates the liars and their relatives because they all bring so much chaos and drama that she can not solve it.
So, according to the last night’s episode no one has the potential to be Big A. Even Tippi the Bird doesn’t have the potential for it because he was not in the last seconds of the episode. I’m so bummed that my Tippi isn’t the A material. :(