4,500 Followers Oneshot
Summary: Sam and the reader decide to carve pumpkins but it doesn’t turn out the way they planned.
Pairing: Sam x Reader
Halloween Request: @winchesterprincessbride
Although it’s a corny holiday, Sam Winchester decides to partake in it because it’s your absolute favorite. And to win major brownie points, he made plans to carve a bunch of pumpkins with you. Knowing it will put you in the best of moods, he plans on using it to his full advantage.
Is that a little self serving? Yes. But Sam needs all of the help that he can get. Tonight’s activity will no longer just be a fun idea with his best friend, it will soon turn into something more. Or at least he hopes so.
Sam Winchester has always been head over heels in love with you and it’s been weighing heavily on him for years. Whether it be his lack of balls or some moron slobbering all over you, it was always the same result. He could never reveal his feelings to you.