Second Chances Pt. 2 (Jeff Atkins X Reader X Zach Dempsey)
There is a part one to this so make sure to go read that first!
— — — — — — — — — — — — — — —
“Can you give me a second chance?” Zach stated. His eyes filled with hope. Before you could answer Jeff came out the doors.
“Y/N I’ve been looking everywhere for you! What are you doi—” He stopped his sentence after seeing who you were with.
“So Y/N will you?” Zach said again, you thought about it but before you could speak Jeff did.
“Will she what?” Jeff asked, while looking at you.
“None of your business.” Zach stated quite harshly. Jeff scoffed,
“Well it’s gonna be my business now because I’m not leaving her alone with the guy who broke her heart.” Jeff said while putting his arm around you.
“You know what, fuck this. I didn’t even want you back anyways. This was just a fucking joke. Obviously I wouldn’t want to be known as the guy who dated a slut.” Zach said.
“You fucking prick!” Jeff said, while punching him. Zach punched him as well and before you knew it it was a full on fist fight. You tried pushing them away but you were too weak. You ran back inside to call someone. You came out with Clay and Justin. Luckily they separated them. You took a look at both of their faces. Blood dripping from their noses, one of them with a busted lip while the others eye started swelling up.
“Bro what happened?” Justin asked confused as to why they were fighting.
“Your friend over here, he’s a dick.” Jeff said while looking at Zach with hatred.
“Jeff can we go home? I can drive just please can we go home?” You asked. Jeff nodded and you two walked towards his car. You opened the car door for him,
“I always open the door for my prince,” you laughed which resulted in Jeff laughing as well. But his ribbed started hurting so then he groaned. You drove back home, the drive was filled with comforting silence. Your parents weren’t home seeing as today was date night for them. You and Jeff walked in and you told him to go to the bathroom. That’s where the first aid kit was. He sat down in the toilet, and you began wiping off all the blood from is face.
“Why did you do it?” You asked.
“I did it because I never want anybody to talk about you like that. You’re not a slut, he never deserved you.” Jeff stated quietly. You were so careful when wiping off the blood. You didn’t know what parts of his face were bruised or not. He just looked at you the whole time.
“What are you staring at?” You asked while chuckling.
“The most beautiful girl ever.” He said, you blushed.
“You’re not too bad yourself, even when you’re covered in blood.” He laughed which led to him groaning because of the pain coming from his rib.
“Can you sleep over pleaseeeeeee?” You whined while putting away all the supplies.
“Sure, it’ll be like old times when I would always sleep over.” You smiled remembering all the memories.
“C'mon let’s go get ready for bed?” You said while walking to your room. You took out some pajamas for yourself and went to the bathroom to change. One you got out you peeked through your door seeing Jeff taking off his shirt.
OF COURSE YOU WERE GONNA STARE HE HAS AN AMAZING BODY! DONT FIGHT ME ON THIS.
“Like what you see?” He said while smirking, that took you out of your thoughts and you blushed. You just ignored the question and walked to your vanity where you would wipe off your makeup. Since Jeff would always sleep over he had a few clothes over in your house, he always slept shirtless with some sweatpants, so basically the only clothes he had over here were sweatpants.
“Why do you wear makeup?” Jeff asked.
“It makes me feel more confident and it makes me not look dead.” You stated.
“But you look so beautiful without it.” Jeff said. You smiled at him while thanking him. You tied your hair in a messy bun and walked over to your bed where Jeff already was. You two would always sleep on the bed so it wasn’t awkward. You hit him with your pillow.
“Do you know how many people would kill to sleep in the same bed with the shirtless Jeff Atkins and you take this as the opportunity to hit me!” He stated. You just laughed and put your head down.
“Go turn off the light.” You mumbled.
“Ughhh I always turn them off it’s your turn.” He said. You sighed and got up but as soon as you did he got up and ran to turn them off.
“I was just kidding I would never make you turn them off.” You rolled your eyes and laid down. He laid down next to you and wrapped his arm around your waist.
“Goodnight princess.” He said, which made you smile and get all cheesy and butterfly in your stomach.
“Goodnight love.” You said back, but little did you know that gave Jeff the same feeling it gave you. Because Jeff has had a crush on you for a while now.
Morning soon came and you woke up to Jeff just staring at you with a smile on his face.
“What are you looking at? Oh no is there drool all over my face?” You said while quickly wiping your face.
“No, you just look cute while sleeping.” He said. You smiled at him and got up.
“C'mon let’s go downstairs.” You said, the both of you went downstairs to see your parents drinking coffee. Your parents looked over and looked surprised when they saw Jeff.
“Jeff you haven’t slept over in so long.” Your father stated, which was true. Jeff would never sleep over while you were dating Zach because he would get extremely jealous.
“What happened to your lip?” Your mom asked worriedly to Jeff.
“Oh I was standing up for someone but I’m fine though.” He stated.
“Hey wanna go out for breakfast?” Jeff asked you. You asked your parents and they said yeah because they were too lazy to cook breakfast. Jeff went to go get ready and he said he’ll be back in a couple of minutes.
You went back to your room and you were about to put on makeup when you remembered what Jeff had told you last night. You smiled and decided not to put on any makeup. You quickly changed and fixed your hair and waited for Jeff downstairs. He rang your doorbell, you said goodbye to your parents and walked out to his car.
You got in and buckled up.
“Where are we going?” You asked turning up the radio a little bit.
“IHOP if you’re okay with it.” He said, you nodded telling him it was fine. The car drive was short and you guys soon arrived. It was a miracle that’ll wasn’t full and that they attended you guys quite fast. You guys ordered your food and waited for it to come.
“You’re not wearing any makeup.” Jeff said while having the biggest smile on his face.
“Yeah, I probably look dead right now.” You said, he shook his head.
“No you look beautiful.” He said while grabbing your hands across the table. You smiled. Your guys’ good soon came and you guys began eating. You grabbed some whip cream from your pancakes and put it on Jeff’s nose.
“Whoops I slipped.” You laughed. He just smirked. He got up pretending to go to the bathroom but instead kissed you. You froze.
“Whoops I fell.” He said. Your stomach filled with butterflies and so did his. You cupped his cheeks and brought him in for another kiss.
“Looks like we’re both falling for each other.” You laughed at that horrible pun.
“Oh Ms Y/L/N I’ve been falling for you since day one.” Jeff smiled.
“Atkins you have won my heart.” You stated, which made him have the biggest smile ever.
“So Ms Y/L/N would you like to be my girlfriend.” Jeff asked, he seemed quite nervous.
“Of course Atkins.” You smiled, while putting more whip cream on his nose. As you guys were eating your breakfast a couple sat on the table next to you guys. You looked to see Zach and the girl he cheated on you with. You tensed up and Jeff noticed so he reached for your hand. You looked over to him and soon enough he connected his lips to yours,
“Let’s go babe,” he stated, you could hear Zach scoff and Jeff smirked. You smirked and followed Jeff. As you walked past Zach you heard him mutter something under his breath which sounded like him saying “slut” you just rolled your eyes.
When you reached Jeffs car both of you burst out laughing,
“He was so jealous.” You said in between laughs. Jeff nodded and you both got in the car. Jeff gave you the aux cord so you played some random songs that both of you knew. Dont by Bryson Tiller came on and Jeff got excited, he loved that song. He knew all the lyrics so he sang to you,
“Fuck ‘em girl I guess he didn’t know any better. Girl that man didn’t show any effort. Do all I can just to show you you’re special. Certain it’s your love that holds me together.” Why did he always sing the most relevant lyrics to you?
“Left hand is steering the other is gripping your thigh.” As he sang that he placed his right hand on your thigh and looked at you while licking his lips. He looked so hot and you wanted to oh so badly kiss his lips, but you couldn’t because that would probably lead to you guys in a car accident. (THIS WAS NOT DONE ON PURPOSE I SWEAR)
You guys soon arrived to your house and before you got out Jeff kissed you,
“Thank you for giving dating a second chance and saying yes to me.” You smiled giving him another kiss.
There you go, a part two. Honestly thank you for the amazing feedback on part one!