SU Theory: Why They Came To Earth--Pink Diamond’s Role
I have no idea if this has been said or speculated anywhere else in the fandom, but I was looking at those murals of the Diamonds again, and something struck me. Something big. This starts off bizarre but I promise it ties together smoothly. - White Diamond’s mural depicts her with this giant halo behind her head, a large circle with what I think is supposed to be rays of light shining down. In her hands safely rests Homeworld, secure and strong in her possession. Above her are other planets we assume she conquered.
Now on to her sisters, Blue and Yellow Diamonds. They have lots of planets around them but look at their heads.
They have much smaller halos. Why?
Y’know who else has the only other giant halo?
We can deduce that all that fancy stained glass jazz behind them is what they’re wearing; YD’s huge shoulders and skirt/leg cape…thing, BD’s dress and WD’s full on royal robe. So we can assume that everything shown in these murals meanssomething.
Why are White Diamond and Pink Diamond shown as seemingly more important than the other two? Because they are/were.
Why? How? Well…
Peridot shared a very important bit of info; Homeworld is running out of resources. Now because of how the show presented it to us, we have no idea for how long Homeworld’s been in that situation. For all we know, it could have been bleeding out for eons now, they live for such a long time.
By “running out of resources”, consider instead that Peridot meant Homeworld is dying. Considering Peridot came from Homeworld proper and not some colony planet, we know they actively make gems on Homeworld. Safe to say, that’s probably what’s draining it dry. Gemkind is a warring race, they conquer other planets to add to their empire, supposedly so they can make more gems.
Now this may seem like a really stupid question but, I always asked myself, why so many? Managing control over that many colonies on a scale like this would be a nightmare even for them with all their power, even with all of their subjects being loyal. Not to mention what it would take to conquer them in the first place. There had to be a driving reason behind it beyond power lust.
I’ve seen a theory floating around that thinks it’s because the Gems are at war with another, more powerful race. But I don’t think that’s why, Peridot just told us why; her lack of skill, the resources problem;
The kinds of gems they can make depends on the planet, what it’s made of and how much of it there is!
Out of every planet they own within their empire, I’d bet my Nintendo collection Homeworld is the planet not only with themost resources, but with the mostvaried kinds of resources! And that’s why Era 2 Peridots are weaker, smaller and have a harder time using abilities and skills their era 1 counterparts would have been able to use easily.
They conquer so many planets so they can make all sorts of gems! This may even explain why certain gems are common af and some are rare!
Let’s say they only had one or two planets that could produce Sapphires. I’d be resistant to making too many of them at once too, since gem production destroys planets–and less resources means Gems with less prowess over their powers…
Peridot having a hard time with metalbending is one thing but ehh.. wouldn’t want a Sapphire with faulty Future Vision. Imagine how disastrous that would be. All it took to throw our Sapphire off was a sweet non-conforming Ruby.
And here’s an even bigger bombshell; who’s to say the homeworld Peridot is talking about isn’t the original one? Maybe Gemkind has had to replace their Homeworld many times. They live forever presumably or until they’re shattered, and even then. I can easily see how one planet alone wouldn’t be nearly enough to keep up with demand.
Blue and Yellow Diamond must have been made somewhere too, anyway.
So that explains the planet-hogging, lets get back down to Earth. Remember the giant halos behind White and Pink Diamond? Yeah, how does any of this relate to those, you ask? Once again, Peri, if you please:
“Resources unique to this world”There it is. Unique enough to make tons of different kinds of gems? Maybe even unique enough to turn the Earth into a New Homeworld?
Yeah, see that sounds like a stretch until I went back and found this.
That’s an Atom. The building block on which all matter is made! Like the matter that makes up the resources they need to produce a full range of gems!! I think Earth Colony wasn’t just a colony. It was going to be a New Homeworld. There are no coincidences in Steven Universe.
We know Blue Diamond was on Earth to fight the rebellion, but maybe she was the original antagonist they had to fight. If Pink Diamond was newly formed when the rebellion started, she’d need someone to guide her. Gems pop out of the ground knowing their place and purpose sure, but this is a Diamond. I have a hard time believing they’d just send a quartz soldier to lead the expedition.
Speaking of the rebellion, that’s another thing. If those planets on the murals are anything to go by, Homeworld has tons of colonies.
If the Earth was only going to be a colony, then… here, look at this for a sec.
All of that. For one colony?? Just a colony? Really? No way. This planet was more important to them than that. Either that or the Diamonds are ridiculously psycho.
Finally, lets not forget, a Diamond was made here. That has to hold some significance as they obviously don’t make a new Diamond on every colony they get. Look at Pink Diamond’s pose. The other Diamonds look powerful and in control, she’s bursting from the ground reaching for the Earth, as if she and this planet were some great hope for them.
That’s why Pink Diamond has the same halo as White Diamond, that’s why they fought so long and hard for the Earth and Pink Diamond; Maybe she was going to be the ruler of a New Homeworld, and our solar system would have become her line of conquered planets.
Now think of Jasper’s unrelenting self-hatred for failing to protect her Diamond, the Cluster, the fused gem experiments and Yellow Diamond’s utter contempt and hate for the Earth. Yikes. Homeworld is fucked up.
With all of the new developments in SU, it’s easy to forget old inconsistencies, but these nonetheless have bearing on some of the current events in the show. When the Crystal Gems and the
Ruby Squad arrive on the Diamond Base in Back to The Moon and Eyeball begins
some dramatic narration.
She says, “Look at this
place – frozen in time. An Era-1 base. Her
Era-1 base. It was a tragedy, what happened to her.”
And the way this
statement was followed up with Navy saying “Who is that anyway?” the answer
being Pink Diamond, we’re led to fill in the blanks and assume this was Pink
But looking at the base
itself, from the outside especially, nothing about its colour scheme or even
its texturing resembles anything of Pink Diamond’s aesthetic.
This leads to an
interesting question of who built the Diamond Base on the moon, why it was
chosen for that location, and what purpose it served, all of which we’ll be
covering in this video.
When we observe how
certain places or objects are associated with characters in Steven Universe,
colour is a big factor. For instance, we know Rose, Lion, and the Alpha
Kindergarten are domains of Pink Diamond because of their dominance of pinks.
The Kindergarten Control
Room, the Hand Ship, and even Peridot are all bright green, which would relate
to Yellow Diamond and hint at a collaboration with Blue Diamond in the new order of Homeworld.
There is a scene in It
Could’ve Been Great in which the camera zooms out and gives us an outsider’s
view of the Moon Base. What we find is that the base is
predominantly in colours of whites and greys, almost matching the colours of
the moon’s surface.
And this would hint at
the only other Diamond we have yet to see in the show. White Diamond.
What’s even more
intriguing is that White Diamond is never mentioned by name in Steven Universe.
We know of her existence primarily because of the Mural in the Moon Base and
her presence in both reincarnations of the Great Diamond Authority logos, as well as the large white bust of her image on Homeworld. But the Diamonds don’t say anything about her, and she hasn’t involved herself in historically important events, such as the Trial of Rose Quartz.
In her depictions, there is a
white shape who takes the position at the top of the logos. This would hearken
back to White Diamond’s gem placement, which is on her forehead. The same white diamond shape is on the old Diamond Authority logo. Later on, the Diamonds are depicted not from the top view, but from the side, giving rise to the new emblem with three triangles.
But something else worth
noting is the aesthetic that each of the Diamonds has in the mural, which
emphasises the possibility that the Moon Base was White’s.
When we look at the
Diamonds side by side in the mural, each Diamond is shown with the number of
colonies and satellites under them.
There is more
information than that.
For instance, looking at
Pink Diamond, the other apparent object in her mural is the cluster of quartz
stones at her feet, which are very similar to the ones we see in Lion’s pocket
One other thing is that
the quartz clusters are coming from the ground, growing upwards.
That would mean Pink is
a little more inexperienced in dealing with colonies, but isn’t necessarily the temporal youngest. She’s growing upward
because she’s still gaining experience and skills in terms of managing planets. On the other hand, White
Diamond’s additional details are emanating outwards and downwards from her
White has the most number
of colonies. Also, white diamonds are the archetypal diamond. That is, the word
diamond is often associated with a white diamond by default.
That could hint at the
dynamic between the diamonds. Even though they were four rulers of the gem
empire, when it came to questions and concerns, White may have been the face of the Great Diamond Authority, not necessarily the leader, but someone who serves as their face in public.
We can find the same
sort of parallels in the other Diamonds.
For instance, Yellow
Diamond’s upper torso appears to be rising from clouds, like a sun poking
through. The sun imagery is also seen in the Yellow Diamond of the Serious
Steven mural. In her hands are not only planets, but also two stars with their
That she was likely in
charge of research and technology could be akin to enlightening or illuminating things that were previously unknown.
Her complement could
have been Blue Diamond, which is why they have the same number of planet
Blue’s territory is the
Lunar Sea Spire, which Bismuth says is “for thinkers to think in.” And that would give the
impression that it housed philosophers and other practitioners of the
discipline we’ve come to label as the humanities.
They would complement
and balance the sheer “rationality” that Yellow’s faction cultivated. If a new
technology were developed, should it be used and why? These are the questions
that might have been asked.
This is also possibly
why Blue Diamond was sent on the diplomatic mission in The Answer even though
the rebels were from Pink Diamond’s colony, and why Rebecca Sugar associates
blue gems with diplomats. The Answer took place in the budding days of the Rebellion, and taking back Earth without a fight was still a viable option. This implies that Pink Diamond was still present then, since Blue Zircon puts PD’s shattering at a time when Rose and the CGs were already well-known and established. Yet Blue was sent on the mission to capture the rebels.
So these points reinforce why the
Diamonds occupy certain positions on the mural. These refer to their roles and not their personalities. It’s also clearer to see now the kind of stress a gem experiences when the role given to her doesn’t match up very well with her personality.
Given this understanding
of the Diamond’s relationships, it seems odd that Pink Diamond’s base would be
far away from her own planet, a place where the warps could not reach.
It contrasts sharply
with the awe that Peridot felt for Yellow Diamond. The latter feels a lot like
someone talking about a celebrity; the former sounded like Jasper knew her
Diamond personally even if we’re given the indication she didn’t.
If we combine that
knowledge with the colour scheme and patterns on the base, even the inside of
the base is white rather than pink. The Base looks more like something of White
Diamond’s. It would then be a question of why something of White Diamond’s domain was so close to Earth.