I was wondering if you know any Wincest fics that are about the boys first discovering their feelings for each other? Maybe they kiss once and freak out and then they have to accept their feelings and admit that they love each other more than they should? Or something similar to that? Thank you so much!
Hi nonnie! I love firsttime so here you go: (these are mostly NC-17)
Just a Kiss by eremir
First in a series of Dean teaching Sam about sex. This one is R, but other fics in the series are NC-17. It’s super sweet and hot with shy Sam and caring big brother Dean.
Courting Death by theproblematique
This is a really, really cool AU featuring reaper!dean and accidentpronehunter!sam. (not sure if this is exactly what you’re looking for but just try it)
TMI by astolat
Basically Dean talking dirty about kinky sex he had with a girl and Sam discovering he wants to be the one having kinky sex with Dean.
Run It All Over by runawaydreamer
They’ve only got each other on the road, so a platonic handjob or two becomes commonplace. And then it becomes more… The first in the amazing West series, these are so hot mmm.
Practice Kissing by whiskyandoldspice
More weecest where Dean teaches Sam about kissing before his first date with a girl, but Sam doesn’t end up going on that date. One of the first wincest fics I ever read and it’s still one of the very best.
I’m sure I’ve read something exactly like what you described but for some reason I am terrible about marking fics so I can remember??? I’m so sorry. Check these out, and also try thewincestlibrary. If you ask there i’m sure they will be able to give you exactly what you’re looking for.