Toby: Highly Gay
Ben: High and Gay
Eyeless Jack: Hentai Material
Jane: THICC Queen
Smile: Urban Dictionary
Jeff: Miss America
Liu: My Bro Was My Plastic Surgeon WBU?
Puppeteer: B My Fren
Bloody Painter: Van Gogh
LJ: Monochrome Toothpick
Tim/Masky: This is David
Brian/Hoodie: Lowkey Dead ( ;) )
could you possibly do personality headcanons if you didn't already..?
I haven’t done these yet! Thank’s for requesting!
Jeff: He’s really gruff and standoffish. It’s hard for him to grow close to certain people because their own personalities harshly clash with his own. He’s the type of person who expects things done right the first time. He won’t hesitate to make you cry. And he’d probably laugh if he did make you cry.
Laughing Jack: He’s an enigma, it’s hard to put a finger on him. His emotions change from any given moment. Like a hurricane, L-Jack is unpredictable and only rolls with people who are as fast paced and crazy as him. Which is why his and Jeff’s friendship is so strong. Laughing Jack is as cruel as Jeff so they both share the same humor. He’s eager to please the very few he looks up to and is described as a kiss-ass by Masky.
Eyeless Jack: He reserves his emotions for those who deserve it. The other Pastas keep it professional with him besides a chosen few. Once you get to know him he’s rather intelligent for a demon, and is eager to call someone out for being a hypocrite. His personality is best described as a deadly know-it-all. He’s like the successful sister in college who’s studying to be a lawyer. Ruthless in his truths E-Jack doesn’t spare feelings. If someone asks him how they look he’ll say what’s on his mind.
Jane the Killer: By now she should know not to be quick to trust but she is. The only people she really doesn’t trust is Jeff and L-Jack. She’s a cheery person considering her circumstances. She’s intelligent as well. Jane has an uncanny knack for telling when one is lying, which has lead her to be wary around some. None really have many quarrels with her. Obviously Jeff and her will fight, but other than that she hasn’t had many issues with the others. She did end up in a tussle with Eyeless Jack once but that was because they were locked in from a blizzard and he hadn’t eaten a human in days. Masky for one, describes her as an angel, but he’s biased.
Masky: Quiet, wrathful. He protects those he cares for to the fullest extent. And would die for a few. He doesn’t speak his mind often but those who have debated with him wouldn’t write him off as unintelligent. In-fact, Jane describes him as a revolutionary savant in the art of combat. Especially hand to hand. Though he is a non-violent person at heart, circumstances have lead him to methods of violence in order to stay alive.
Hoodie: No one really knows much about him. He truly does try to keep away from them, which has lead to Jeff calling him an “Asshole who thinks he’s better than everyone.” But Jeff really is one to talk. He stays away from them during mealtime, hunts, and recreation. Leading Eyeless Jack to describe him in reports as a recluse.
Toby: Jeff describes him as Slender’s pet but lately Toby has been detached from the man. The closest person he is friends with, Eyeless Jack, enjoys his company. Toby shows extreme interest for the forest and shows great care for the animals inhabiting it. Jane also talks with him. He’ll come up to her room and sit on the ground to stare at her until she notices him. He doesn’t talk as often anymore. But does nod his head enthusiastically when anyone talks to him about certain things. The only person he really talks for is E-Jack. They’ll laugh and walk in the forest, well E-Jack hops from tree to tree but still. They’ll converse about anything from killing techniques to how to properly butcher a human. The closed off boy really just needs someone to relate to.
Jeff: he says he listens to heavy metal, because he likes being seen as punk rock. But in all honesty, he just jams out to Melanie Martinez when he’s alone.
BEN: I’ve mentioned this before, but rap. When he’s high, he likes things that are a more chill kinda thing (lil uzi vert and kendrick lamar kinda shit), but when he isn’t high then it’s things like Eminem he listens to.
EJ: he likes things that are indie (independent); troye sivan and stuff like that. It calms him in times like of stress
LJ: he’s that one weirdo who has no particular taste, he’ll like anything no matter the genre. His favourite artist is highkey britney spears.
Sally: That creepy music that most youtube channels make nightcore remixes of. Things like Hide and seek is her favourite.
Masky: He likes classic rock, Nirvana and Pink Floyd kinda stuff. He has band posters rolled up and collected under his bed.
Hoodie: This guy really likes shit like Neon Trees and Simon Curtis. I don’t even know what this genre is called but anyways.
Toby: He REALLY likes pop. Katy Perry and Selena Gomez, mainstream stuff, y'know? He likes how the beat matches his happiness and the lyrics are just fun, something unusual in the life of a murderer.
Bloody Painter: Classical music. It calms him and helps him sleep when he hasn’t for so long. It also inspires him to make more art so yay.
Puppeteer: like Laughing Jack, he’s everywhere. Alternative is his favourite though, especially bands like Set It Off and Get Scared.
Slenderman: this hoe likes to pretend he’s classical af, and will listen to Beethoven and Yiruma in front of others. Behind doors? Marilyn Manson.
A lot of songs fit the creepypasta. And I know Nina isn’t considered a creepypasta but she is on this list anyway.
Jeff - Throne by Bring Me The Horizon
BEN - Drown by Bring Me The Horizon
Jane - Summertime Sadness by Lana Del Rey
Eyeless Jack - Duality by Slipknot / Snuff by Slipknot
The Bloody Painter - Everybody’s Fool by Evanescence
Clockwork - Down With The Sickness by Disturbed
Masky - Medicine by Hollywood Undead
Hoodie - Heavy by Linkin Park
Ticci Toby - Save Me by Hollywood Undead
Sally - Sippy Cup by Melanie Martinez / Dead To Me by Melanie Martinez
Laughing Jack - Pit of Vipers by Simon Curtis
Slender - Every Slender song out there
Nina - Can You Feel My Heart by Bring Me The Horizon
Liu - I’m Not Okay ( I Promise ) by My Chemical Romance / Pit of Vipers by Simon Curtis / Can You Feel My Heart by Bring Me The Horizon / Monster by BIGBANG / King For a Day by Pierce The Veil / California Dreaming by Hollywood Undead / So much more fam Liu is my favorite so he got special treatment.
This isn’t everyone or every song that fits them so add on if you’d like.