andrew holbrooke

Rosewood Suspects & Their Potential Motives for Being A

If only that iconic Black Hoodie turned around to reveal one of the following familiar faces instead of CeCe Drake’s. 

We are allowed to dream, so here is a list of possible motives for each of Rosewood’s leading suspects & why they might have targeted the PLLs if they ended up being A:

With all of these terrible, yet justifiable motives, instead we got this:

Who is -A?

We have been told by IMK that Charles is A. On Good Morning America, we were told that A has been in at least 5 episodes. I checked on IMDB and wiki pages and here’s the list of characters who appeared in 5 or more episodes:
Samara
Zach
Clark
Alex
Eddie
Jonny
Kate
Lorenzo
Principal Hackett
Meredith
Holden
Nate/Lynden
Maggie
Sydney
Talia
Dr Sullivan
Jackie
Sean
Travis
Jake
Ted
Sara
Cece
Andrew
Shana
Holbrook
Ian
Wren
Barry
Wilden
Noel
Maya
Garrett
Lucas
Mike
Jason
Melissa
Paige
Jenna
Toby
Caleb
Mona
Ezra
Ashley
Tom
Byron
Ella
Kenneth
Jessica
Wayne
Pam
Peter
Veronica
Spencer
Emily
Aria
Hanna
Alison

Take away all female characters and we have:
Zach
Clark
Alex
Eddie
Jonny
Lorenzo
Holden
Nate/Lynden
Sean
Travis
Jake
Ted
Andrew
Holbrook
Barry
Ian
Wren
Wilden
Noel
Garrett
Lucas
Mike
Jason
Toby
Caleb
Ezra
Tom
Byron
Kenneth
Wayne
Peter

Take away dads and dead people:


Zach
Clark
Alex
Eddie
Jonny
Lorenzo
Holden
Sean
Travis
Jake
Ted
Andrew
Holbrook
Barry
Wren
Noel
Lucas
Mike
Jason
Toby
Caleb

Now take away those who are not Caucasian (due to home videos, we know Charles is Caucasian)

Zach
Alex
Jonny
Holden
Sean
Travis
Jake
Ted
Andrew
Holbrook
Wren
Noel
Lucas
Mike
Jason
Toby
Caleb
Ezra

Take away those who are related to a liar or have been in the same room as A at the same time (as well as Caleb and Ezra since they were with Ali when the girls got out of the dollhouse, meaning neither could be Charles since he was in there):

Zach
Alex
Jonny
Holden
Sean
Travis
Jake
Ted
Andrew
Holbrook
Wren
Noel
Lucas
Toby

Now take away those who have been accused and cleared of being A:

Zach
Alex
Jonny
Holden
Sean
Travis
Jake
Ted
Holbrook
Wren
Noel
Lucas

Now take away high school aged kids since Charles is around 7 years older than Alison:
Zach
Jonny
Ted
Holbrook
Wren

Take away Holbrook because he kissed Alison and if he’s Charles, that implies incest

Take away Ted because he’s too old.

We have Zach, Jonny and Wren left.

Zach was in Europe with Ella so that’s unlikely. Also, though it isn’t confirmed, it’s implied he’s in his 30s.

Jonny could be possible, but he tells Spencer that he her mom sued his granny’s nursing home for his mom. Veronica wouldn’t have allowed someone to live in their pool house unless she knew who they were.

That leaves Wren. He has no backstory that can be confirmed. He is the right age. He’s sketchy as hell. He has supposedly been in England with Melissa, but when Spencer was there, did we see Wren even once?

  • writers during season 5&6: PLL isn't about the ships!!
  • pointless love interests in season 5&6: travis, zack, holbrook, talia, andrew, jonny, colin, sara, lorenzo, clark
  • things that are actually important to the plot that happened in seasons 5&6: