honestly season 2 proved that lance is as much of a conspiracy theorist/believer as keith was but obviously doesn’t want him to know about it.
keith: *walks into lance’s room* hey lance can yo-
keith: oh. he’s not here. hm. well i’ll just-
keith: *sees his shrine and conspiracy board dedicated to the Jersey Devil*
keith: oh my god…
keith: OH MY GOD?!
keith: *sprints out of the room*
keith: *eventually finds lance*
keith: AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA WHAT THE FUCK YOU BELIEVEINTHEJERSEYDEVILTOO??
lance: *RUNS THE FUCK AWAY AS FAST AS HE CAN*