A.D did scary stuff, but the only time in pretty little liars where i was actually scared was during the dollhouse episodes. Still think it's one of the best episodes of the whole show. Whats your top five pll episodes?
In terms of scariness I can’t really think of a time when I’ve been scared, so here’s some general favourites:
4x10 because shady Wren rises
3x23 because shady Wren also rises and the plot makes me gag. Mona led Spencer to proof that CeCe and Wren were evil (in the form of a BOARD GAME) and Wren came in all creepy and had to cover himself. And she believed him!!!! She found out who A was and just walked away from it. Loooordt.
The First Secret?? With the Halloween party and Ali being chased and stuff
Both Dollhouse eps for sure. Iconic!
Probably 7x19 for the sheer beauty that was Mona and CeCe.