According to the Fatwa of all Shia Marja Taqleed and Mujtahideen, it is Haram to slander the companions or the wives of the Prophet صل الله عليه وآله. Those who do it aren’t doing it based on Shia Islam because it contradicts with Shia Islam. Do you even know your own religion? You form answering by only copy paste from different Shia websites without any independent research.
I copy pasted? I beg you put my answer into google and
see if you get a single word for word match. Just because you find it difficult
to write a structured answer, doesn’t mean I do.
First of all, slander and insulting are different to
cursing (لعن). Cursing is
asking God to Withdraw His Mercy from someone. It’s in the Holy Quran. Slander
implies what’s being said is baseless and not true. When the Shias
critique certain wives of the Prophet or certain ‘companions’, we do it based
on evidence. It’s not slander. We ask Allah (swt) to remove His Mercy from
the enemies of Islam because it is the Sunnah of the Prophet (saw) and his
Secondly, some Marāji have prohibited cursing,
yes. But that’s a small number. Grand Ayatollah Sayyid Ali Sistani(may
Allah lengthen his life) actually came out with a statement saying that
based on the conduct of Aisha towards the Prophet (saw), we cannot help but
Sayed Sadiq al-Shirazi(may Allah lengthen his
life) said: ‘’It is permissible to Curse the enemies of the
Ahlulbayt (as)’’. So there’s a difference in opinion. Even Khomeini wrote
against Aisha in some of his book. So it’s not black and white really.
And if the examples to follow are the Ahlulbayt (as),
then I follow them in their example of speaking out about the oppression that
they were under. Unapologetically. If Sunnis prefer to love oppressors that’s
Tabarra (disassociating with the enemies of the
Ahlulbayt) is one of the important duty of a Shia. Anyone who claims to love
the Ahlulbayt (as) has to disassociate from their enemies. This is a part of
our Furu’ al-Deen and it is Wajib. It has the exact same
importance as Salah or Zakat or Hajj.
I find it ironic how you people, who have blindly been
fed love of these oppressors, have the audacity to tell me that I don’t know my
own religion. Alhamdulillah, my religion is based on dissociation. Yours on the
other hand, is based on a fairytale of a LaLa land. Seriously, don’t try to
tell Shias about their religion dude, you’ll only embarrass yourself.
May Allah (swt) Curse the enemies of the Ahlulbayt (as)
from the first to last.