You Don’t Believe Me (p. 8)
- so it’s like 4 A.M. and i’ve spent the last hour reading “You Don’t Believe Me” and it’s sooo good!! it’s killing me omg you’re such a great writer :) please post part 8 soon!!
- I need part 8 and I need this whole story to end well with luke and y/n
- PART EIGHT PART EIGHT PART EIGHT❤️❤️❤️
- You’ve got to do a part 8, part 7 was amazing 😭
- PART OF OF YOU DONT BELIEVE ME PLEASE!!! I LOVE THIS STORY SO MUCH AND SHE IS FINALLY GONNA BE WITH LUKE!!!
- Please continue with You Don’t Believe Me? I accidentally found the series and read all seven parts in a row and I don’t want to stop reading now! :)
- i started reading You Don’t Believe Me last night and couldn’t stop! i love it soooo much! please please please post part 8 soon!!
- Nooooooooooooooooo omg why’d you have to do that it was so perfect why does everyone hate Michael like seriously every fic I’ve read they have always made Michael out to be the bad guy but how he’s the cutest thing and he’d never do anything like that and it bugs me but it was good and I want a part 8
OK I’m addicted to “you dont believe me” now. I really need the next part :D!!!
Plot Line: After everything Y/N talks to Michael and Luke drops a bomb.
Smut: None. Next chapter, I promise.
I hope you enjoy this! Don’t forget to
request for more parts of this, or even for a future imagine/series
ect! My requests are open! And I look forward to seeing what you guys
come up with.
Part One // Part Two // Part Three // Part Four // Part Five // Part Six // Part Seven
Walking into the living room I was smiling from
ear to ear as I saw two sleeping bodies, Calum and a girl with
beautiful hair curled up next to each other. So this was the famous
Kasia I had heart all about? Looking over at Luke with a smile he
silently giggled as Calum let out a snore that made us look at each
other before slapping hands over our mouths to stop even more
laughter spilling out. Luke nudged his head in the direction of the
door and I nodded following him. Me and Luke were hand in hand
whispering to each other when a body stepped out in front of us,
eyebrow raised as his vision went from our hands to our faces and
then back to our hands.
“Ashton..” I murmured not looking at him, I
still remembered that night– we hadn’t really spoken about it or
really to each other and it hadn’t gone unnoticed by the rest of
them. Luke let go of my hand as he walked out giving us space.
“I’m sorry…” Ashton mumbled almost
inaudible as I gnawed on my lip nodding at his words. “No, I’m
really sorry Y/ N. I shouldn’t have gotten involved and I shouldn’t
have let you walk home alone. I mean what if something had really
happened to you? First of all I’d never forgive myself and you
wouldn’t be here..” Ashton trailed off as he ran a hand through his
hair with a loud sigh. I looked up finally and I saw the sorrow and
despair In his eyes. It didn’t say anything to him because I had lost
my words. Instead I took a step forward and wrapped my arms around
his frame and pushed my head into his chest. I had missed my cuddle
buddy. It only took a few seconds before he enveloped me into his
arms and rested his chin upon my head.
“It’s OK Ashton…” I whispered as I ran a
soothing hand up and down his back and he quickly sighed in content.
Ashton’s hand came up to play with my soft locks, as he always did–
he said it calmed him down and made him feel at peace.
“Y/N…It’s none of my business but why were
you and Luke holding hands?” Ashton asked hesitantly.
“D-Did Michael not tell you?” I asked, and I
didn’t even realise it but my voice cracked.
“Tell me what?” Ashton asked confused as he
furrowed his eyebrows. I shook my head taking a few seconds to
compose myself, scared I’d break down. I knew I loved Luke but
Michael had still broken my heart with what he did. Now my hand had
been replaced as Ashton rubbed my back instead.
“Y-You know that night me and Luke kissed and
we argued and I ran?” I asked, and Ashton nodded squeezing me
tighter as another sorry left his lips. I sighed burying my face into
him even more. “well after me and Luke kissed, I ran, and little did
I know the entire time Michael had been shoving his dick in some
other girl anyway..” I trailed off at the end and felt Ashton
stiffen as he pulled away looking at me with fury blazing in his
“He did fucking what? A kiss is bad yes, but
sleeping with someone…that’s unforgivable…” Ashton yelled the
last part making me jump away and to shudder. This was the side of
Ashton that always scared me a little. Ashton shook his head
furiously running an angry hand through his hair.
“I’m going to break up with him Ashton, this
whole thing wasn’t meant to happen any ways..” I murmured and Ashton
“What do you mean?” He asked, once again
confused. I sighed as I looked down to the floor.
“Originally me and Michael only dated so I
could make Luke jealous after everything went down with Callie. He
knew I was hurting and wanting to make sure I didn’t look pathetic
and then we kissed…and we liked each other but it was all so messed
up” I breathed out and Ashton looked at me before laughing, I kinked
my eyebrow. “Why are you laughing?” I asked.
“Well you see I knew there was something that
just didn’t sit right at the beginning!” Ashton exclaimed as I
rolled my eyes. “But I was right! At the very beginning I kind of
guessed..I just couldn’t put my finger on it..” Ashton admitted, and
I nodded until I heard a cough behind me. Turning around Luke’s eyes
fell on me, and I sent him a smile. Walking over to us he looked at
“Could you give us a minute?” Luke asked, and
Ashton nodded walking away. I looked at Luke who just stared right
back at me with wide eyes.
“What?” I asked, as my smile turned to a
“A-At the beginning it wasn’t real between you
two?” Luke asked astonished as I nodded gnawing at my lip as I
“Yeah, It was Michael’s idea and you’d hurt my
feelings and I was–”
“I’m not mad..I’m kind of relieved in a way. I
mean I know you guys eventually fell for each other but that day in
the hallway when you kissed…it bothered me more than you’d ever
realised because that morning was the morning I realised I didn’t
even love Callie anymore..” Luke admitted and my heart had began to
hammer at my chest. I opened my lips and closed them again unsure of
what exactly I should say. “I love you, Y/N. I always did, that day
at the pool when we were kids was just the beginning..if not before
that” Luke whispered as he took a step closer. But the sound of a
key going into the door made us jump apart as a red puffy eyed
Michael walked in with tears still falling down his cheeks. But he
stopped dead in his tracks as he saw me and Luke looking at him.
“Y/N…” Michael croaked and my chest broke
all over again as I kept my gaze trained on the broken looking boy
before me. Running a hand to the back of my head I looked over to
“It’s my turn to ask, could you give us a
minute?” I asked, as Luke gave a smile to me and then a sad one to
Michael as he went to join Ashton in the kitchen and their chatter
began in the background.
Michael coughed trying to clear his throat but
I was quick to beat him to the punch as I shook my head, leaning my
back against the wall as I crossed my hands over my abdomen. I felt
sadness every time I looked at Michael. “I can’t do this any
more..” I whispered but in that second something in my tone must
have gave me away as Michael’s fist collided with the wall making me
jump and stare at him jaw agape.
“It’s because of Luke, I always knew it was
Luke. It’s the soul reason I slept with her because I knew this day
would come. Where Luke would be there to save you from a mistake I
made and I would have to watch you walk straight into his open
fucking arms” Michael barked, but the tears were coming faster now.
His cheeks looked raw and painful and bite marks littered his lips
from his nerves. I felt bad but I couldn’t do this again, I wouldn’t
be able to trust him and I wouldn’t trust my own feelings around
Michael took a few seconds to collect himself
as I took a step further away from him before a new wave of tears
began which quickly turned to sobs as he slid down the wall, his face
falling into his hands, knee’s bent as he rested upon them.
“Go to him Y/N..” Michael choked and I
couldn’t help but not be angry at him as I took a seat beside him
mirroring the way he sat except my head leaned back against the wall
as I took in a deep breath.
“This was inevitable that this would happen
Michael, I think we fooled ourselves in the charade that we were
playing. We got so caught up in the make believe that we truly though
we had feelings…” I said with a sigh but Michael just shook his
“I’ve liked you since we were kids, the
comments, the mean banter…I liked you. You were always too
oblivious to realise the people around you liked you. God, even
Ashton had a crush on you for a while..” Michael stated and I just
raised my eyebrows at this new information. “But– I can’t be mad at
you for choosing Luke. You guys are that couple that people fucking
read books about.” Michael whispered and I placed a hand on his
“I love you Michael, but I can’t love you like
you need to be loved” I admitted and he nodded as he sniffled,
obviously holding back more tears.
“I’m going to go to my room, I just need some
space..” Michael murmured as I nodded watching him get up.
“I love you, Y/N” was the last thing he said
as I saw him take the stairs sluggishly. I felt relieve but I still
felt heavy hearted as I saw a sheepish looking Luke walk in. I sighed
as I pushed to stand up and was instantly enveloped in Luke’s arms.
“What do you want to do?” Luke asked
soothingly as he rocked back and fourth in the hug and I sighed with
contentment at the feeling of home that I always found with Luke and
“Could you just walk me home? I’m pretty
tired?” I asked as I felt the part of today wearing me down even
though I’d already slept. Luke nodded when his obnixously loud phone
began to ring. He took a step back offering me an apologetic smile,
as he shoved the phone right to his ear without checking the caller
“Hello?” Luke sang happily and I almost
giggled before I saw his expression drop and I instantly stopped
“A-Are you sure?” Luke asked, his voice
shaking as he gulped loudly. “Callie please calm down, I’ll be there
In a second.” He paused. “No I promise, I will be there.” Luke
murmured before he pulled the phone away from his ear slowly.
“What is it Luke? What’s wrong?” I asked
quickly. Why was Callie calling?
“She's—She’s pregnant Y/N” Luke whimpered
and I felt my heart plummet.
I guess happiness just wasn’t in my cards.