My top Doctor Who historicals

(I have a…loose opinion on what a “historical” story is, I’m just taking it to mean any story with a historical setting, and these are only the ones I’ve gotten through, not in any specific order because I would never be able to rank them ahhahaha)


-Fallen Gods (Telos Novella)

-The Turing Test (EDA)

-Empire of Glass (VMA)

-Ghost Light

-The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances

-Human Nature (either version, episode or VNA)

-Vincent and the Doctor

-Son of the Dragon (audio)

-Lost in Time (SJA episode)

-Camera Obscura (EDA)

-Dark Horizons (NSA)

-Gallifrey: A Blind Eye (yes this counts shut uP)

-The Chimes of Midnight (audio)

-Apocrypha Bipedium (Short Trip)

-Doctor Who and the Pirates (audio)

-The Kingmaker (audio)

i’m reading through some of the plots of unmade sarah jane adventures episodes and honestly “sarah jane goes to mars and torchwood are also on mars and there’s a dalek trying to blow up mars” is something i would have loved to see

13 Bannerman Road is where Sarah Jane Smith lives, and it’s home to things way beyond your imagination. There’s an extraterrestrial supercomputer in the wall, her son, a genetically engineered boy genius, a schoolgirl investigator across the road, and a whole universe of adventure, right here on the doorstep.

  • Ready?


How is it that every DW spinoff handles things like race, sexuality, backgrounds, major themes, etc… Way better than Doctor Who itself does?

Torchwood shows us what happens when you cut yourself off from humanity (Captain Jack Harkness), when you think you know what’s best but you’re WRONG (Gwen FUCKING Cooper), and when you are willing to do whatever it takes to save the ones you love (Owen Harper, Toshiko Sato, and the brilliant Ianto Jones).

The Sarah Jane Adventures has a cast of teen characters PLAYED BY TEENAGERS, and is full of adult themes for an audience of children - because they know that kids can handle it when explained properly. It deals with death, loss, grief, homelessness, divorce, orphans, and more. Its got an amazingly diverse cast, and Luke Smith was going to come out as queer later on in the show if it had kept on.

I can’t say much about Class - mainly because I havent seen much of it yet. Sorry! But I do know that it also has an amazingly diverse cast, and several lgbt characters.

What If?: The Sarah Jane Adventures

Original Airdate: 2007-2011

The Sarah Jane Adventures was a CBBC series, revolving around investigate journalist and former time traveller Sarah Jane Smith (Elisabeth Sladen). Along with her young friends Luke, Rani, Clyde and Sky, Sarah Jane combatted extraterrestrial threats to the earth. The series was created and executive produced by Russell T Davies, the man behind the relaunch of Doctor Who. The series was a children’s spinoff of the long-running Who, with Sarah Jane herself already a well established and incredibly popular character from the series.

The Sarah Jane Adventures was a great success, winning legions of fans - both children and adult- and numerous awards. However, midway through filming of the fifth series, Sladen sadly lost a closely guarded battle with cancer. Filming was immediately stopped and the BBC announced production on the series would not continue, naturally. 


Since Sladen’s death in 2011, various tidbits about where the show was heading have been revealed in magazine articles and interviews. They include: 

  • Three stories of series 5 remained unproduced at the time of Lis Sladen’s death. Those were Meet Mr Smith, The Thirteenth Floor and The Battle of Bannerman Road.
  • Meet Mr Smith was due to star Alexander Armstrong (the voice of Mr Smith) in a physical capacity. The story would see Mr Smith be transformed into a human, by an alien called Ozmo. Ozmo would force Mr. Smith to work for him, carrying out certain tasks for his nefarious scheme.
  • The Thirteenth Floor would begin in a newspaper office, where a journalist would go missing. The next day, Rani would begin a work experience placement at the office and would be intrigued by the mystery of the missing journalist.
  • This was to be a Halloween special episode, taking influence from The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe.
  • The Thirteenth Floor script was cannibalised and restructured into an episode of the first series of Wizards Vs. Aliens, the series created by the SJA production team to save a full film crew from going out of work.
  • The Battle of Bannerman Road was to be written by show creator and executive producer, Russell T Davies, and looked to be one of the man’s typically loud finales.
  • Former Doctor Who companion, Jo Grant (Katy Manning) and her grandson Diego would return in the story, last seen in 2010’s SJA story Death of the Doctor.
  • Professor Rivers (Floella Benjamin) and The Shopkeeper were also due to return.
  • Long running series villain,The Trickster, was to return. In this episode it would be revealed that he instilled his essence into Sky at the moment of her creation, effectively making her his daughter. The Trickster had been manipulating events to bring Sky and Sarah Jane together.
  • After a long will they/won’t they? Clyde and Rani would finally get together in this story.
  • 13 Bannerman Road may have been blown up at the climax of the story.
  • Clyde and Rani may also have been written out of the series at this point. Both actors felt they were ready to leave the series at this point, but no final decisions were made before production came to its sudden stop.
  • If a sixth series of The Sarah Jane Adventures was commissioned, Russell T Davies hoped to mix things up by relocating Sarah Jane to the fictional Foxglove Village
  • A sixth series would Also see an adventure starring Ace (Sophie Aldred), companion to the Seventh Doctor, and a cameo by the man himself, Sylvester McCoy.
  • In the audio commentary for Death of the Doctor (available only on the Doctor Who story The Green Death DVD), Russell T Davies revealed that were the show to continue, Luke Smith would have been revealed to be gay, per the request of the BBC. The corporation wanted to have "just a normal gay character" on children’s BBC.  

Seeing what was lying ahead for the series makes it all the more upsetting it was halted in such a manner. Though there are a lot of morsels of information here that would excite fans -old and young alike- perhaps the most interesting planned development was Luke’s sexuality. The series was known and praised for the way it tackled sensitive topics for youngsters, including divorce, loss and homelessness. It would have been a bold move by the BBC and the production team, but looking at the talent behind the series, the chances are it would have played out brilliantly.

It’s also interesting to think of what the series would have been up to in Doctor Who’s 50th anniversary year. Russell T Davies has always unashamedly celebrated the series and its mythology in his work for it, so the chances are he would have went all-out in this landmark year for the franchise. Is anyone else revelling in imagining every companion ever paying a visit to Bannerman Road?


Elisabeth Sladen Appreciation Post

‘I’ve seen amazing things out there in space but strange things can happen wherever you are. I’ve learned that life on Earth can be an adventure too.’

I can’t believe it’s been 7 years since this wonderful, stunning woman died. I loved The Sarah Jane Adventures growing up and among over things I have this show to thank for my love of Doctor Who. It is no mistake that Sarah Jane Smith was so deeply loved across generations of fans and that is all down to Lis and the incredible presence that she has brought to both DW and SJA. 

So, for another year…

Goodbye, my Sarah Jane.