Ohhhh, Nonny. You had to go big, didn’t you? This is hard and makes me want to rip my hair out but I’m also very, very excited to talk about it. To make it a tiny bit easier for me to choose, I’m adding some rules: 1) I’m going to only allow myself one scene per season, 2) I’m not going to allow myself to talk about any scene I’ve already written about in a meta post, and 3) since you asked for Brian/Justin, it needs to be a scene where both Brian and Justin shine and is significant to their relationship (so for instance, the “fucking chicken soup” scene is definitely one of my faves of S4, but that’s primarily Justin’s moment, so it’s been eliminated). Because honestly, otherwise we’d be here all day because I’d blow a fuse trying to come up with something. And then, just to make things extra interesting for the sex scenes, I’m not going to allow myself to choose any of the scenes crossroadscastiel chose in this post because honestly I agree with all of her choices 5000% so if I eliminate those, it might make it, again, just a smidgen easier to answer your question. Also, I’m genuinely going to only try to keep it to a few sentences per scene, just because otherwise we’d be here all day, but if you’re really curious about one scene or another and want me to go more in depth, let me know. Cool? Cool.
So, let’s begin!