Based on everyone’s responses, the consensus seems to be that he’s a Mediterranean House Gecko. However, once I researched I found out that they aren’t really in Ohio so he most likely came in on one of our trucks. Several people told me to put him outside but I don’t want to do that since he would most likely die due to our cold weather here. One person said to kill him since he’s an invasive species but I’m not doing that either. So I’ve decided to keep him as a pet because I want him to have the best possible chance at living. So I would like everybody to welcome Ducky to the family!