Wait wait wait I'm really confused I'm sorry! In the future, is Beth actually going to come back on the show? Or are we talking about writing a fanfic or whAt? Either way is okay with me but I'm just really confused that's all.
well… to the average viewer it seemed like Beth died right? didn’t it seem that way? but then some really really observant people watched all the episodes with a really close eye and broke things down scene by scene… im not talking just any ol joe. I’m tallking people with degrees in literature have been helping this along too.
Now stay with me and just think about this for a quick sec… there are a lot of people who have determined that everything we are seeing points to Beth’s death being a fake-out. Remember when the promos for the Mid season premier aired and showed a funeral? Nicotero said that was done on purpose so that people would automatically assume it was Beth’s funeral. But it wasn’t. We now know it was Tyreese’s. They have never showed what happened to Beth’s body. Also, Nicotero slipped up and said they processed some 800 walkers for the MSF. Did you see 800 walkers? Because I didn’t. A certain spoiler site got information WAY ahead of Coda that Beth was a goner. Despite everything on screen alluding to Carol’s death. I, personally, think the spoiler was done on purpose to hide something even bigger. The same spoiler site also apparently got word that Beth would “for sure” be seen in ground during episode 5X09… which didn’t happen. The basic theory is, somehow Beth’s body was left behind. During the Season 4 finale Rick put his sheriff’s hat on her and said “there’s a new sheriff in town”… there have been a lot of parallels between Beth and Rick. Then we heard “its been 3 weeks since Atlanta”… Andrew Lincoln confirmed Rick was in a coma for 3 weeks. The music box suddenly coming alive. There are just a LOT of subtle things that, when all is said and done and Beth returns, people are going to want to re-watch all the episodes and say to themselves “Holy shit, its been in front of me all along”