The killer is Kieran
After last night’s episode, here are some of my reasons for believing that Mr. 17 Going on 30 is our killer.
1. He has a motive: He lost his father due to the first killings, so he would taunt Audrey over it because he blames her for it.
2. His height and strength: I know that it could be anyone in the costume during production, and that with Emma’s current psychological issues, she could have super human strength, but Kieran is the only one with the body to match.
3. Ms. Lang’s reaction: She screamed upon seeing both Emma and Kieran, and why is that? One of them has to be the killer, or there’s a new loop we don’t of yet.
4. Haley’s Special Friend: Haley mentioned having a boyfriend and her constant attacks against Emma could be that she’s jealous of Emma/Kieran. And her dropping to her knees to “find a place to put her lips.” I mean, yeah she could drop on her knees to please a girl, too, but the whole knee-dropping-in-the-media thing is the common stance for bj’s.
5. Kieran was the only one we didn’t see when all the lights went out at the party. Noah and Zoe were seen, as were Audrey and Emma, but Kieran didn’t show up until after the scene with Haley. (So did Stavo, but he seems too obvious?)
BUT, was he Piper’s accomplice? The episode where Piper and Will are attacked, who was that in the costume? And what do the adults know? Who was that in the photo holding Emma with the fact sketched out? HOW was Piper’s body preserved so well? For every reason I find that Kieran is the killer, I find another reason why he isn’t….