New York- Brendon adn Sarah Urie (poly) Part two
Request- wait so are you doing a part 2 for that Brendon and Sarah fic that’s about his broadway show? if you are can you make it like just really sweet, but with more Brendon than Sarah. thank you love your writing.
You got back home early that next morning. You had already felt the difference you desperately needed to feel. You felt at home even though Brendon and Sarah were across the country. You missed them terribly, but you knew what you needed and that was space.
As soon as you got home you called Brendon and Sarah. It was 8 am in New York, so they didn’t care. They were happy to hear from you and told you that you sounded happier already.
You went to your room you usually share with Brendon and Sarah and you plopped down on the big bed. You were so tired you feel asleep and didn’t wake up until noon. It was 3 in new York and Brendon would have been just getting out of rehearsal. Even though you weren’t there you knew what was going on. That’s something you didn’t miss about being in New York, it was too busy and scheduled for your liking.
The next few days you were constantly talking to Sarah and Brendon via text and facetime. Brendon’s opening night of Kinkny boot was tomorrow and they didn’t know you were coming back for it. You had spent a total of 12 days away from them and that’s all you needed to be back to your normal self.
“I still don’t think I’m ready to come back. I’m sorry Bren, I wish I was there to see you on opening night.” you lied over facetime.
“It’s okay. Don’t feel bad. I know you’ll be cheering me on from across the country. I hope you can come back soon though.” he said.
“Me too.” Sarah said from beside him, both making puppy dog faces.
“But I don’t want you back here until you are 100% happy you hear me Y/N. I always want you both to be as happy as possible and if Califonia makes you happy then I’ll see you when I get back.” Brendon explained and he sounded so caring.
“Thanks for understanding, but look I have to go. I love you guys so so much.” you said realizing it was almost midnight and you had to leave in the next hour.
“Love you beautiful.” Sarah said.
“Love you Y/N. Miss you.” Brendon said blowing a kiss.
“Miss you too. Bye.” you said and ended the call.
You finished cleaning up the house before saying goodbye to California again. You were going to be landing in New York around 7 am, then you were going to stay at a hotel and surprise both Sarah and Brendon after his performance. The only thing was you were going to have to stay out of the way of fans, so they didn’t ruin the surprise.
You made it to the hotel by 9 safely and you never thought you would say this, but you missed the loud city.
You decided to pass the time by ordering some food. You got ready at 5:30, knowing you should get there a little early because it was going to be so packed.
Once at the theater everything became so real. This was Brendon’s dream and you loved being there to support him, even though it wasn’t ever step of the way, he knew you were supporting him.
You saw Sarah sitting in the front row with some close family and friends. You had to do everything you could to not go up there and hug her and tell her how much you missed her.
You found your seat near the back and a few people recognized you.
“Are you Y/N Urie?” one girl asked.
“Yeah I am. Can you guys do me a favor and not tell anyone I’m here though, it’s a surprise.” you told them and they understood.
You carried on conversation with them for a while when your phone started buzzing.
You excused yourself and went to the lobby where you answered Brendon’s facetime call.
“Hey babe. I just wanted to show you how great I looked before I go on.” Brendon said turning the camera so you could see him in the mirror.
“You look amazing Bren. I love you so much. Good luck out there. You know how much I wish I could have been there tonight, right?” you said making sure he couldn’t see the background of where you stood.
“I know, but remember I want the best for you and I don’t want to see you until you are feeling better.” you smiled at him. “I have to go we’re starting in about 20 minutes. I love you to the moon Y/N.”
“I love you too Brendon. Give Sarah and the puppies kisses for me. Break a leg.” you said and the call ended soon after.
You went back to your seat and waited for the show to begin. When Brendon finally came out on stage you thought you were going to cry tears of happiness.
After an amazing performance from the cast you knew it was almost time to go see Brendon and Sarah.
You started making your way to the backstage where Brendon’s dressing room was. The crew knew you so you had no problems getting back there. You phone started to ring as you turned down the hall where the room was located. It was Sarah.
“Hey beautiful. How was the show?” you asked her.
“It was truly amazing. Brendon is getting out of costume right now and we wanted to talk to our love.” she explained.
“That’s amazing. Look I’ll call you back in a minute but I have to do something really quick.” you said as you approached the closed door with Brendon’s name on it.
“Ok. Talk to you soon.” she said then hung up.
You knocked on the door after a few seconds.
“One minute.” you heard Brendon say.
You waited for a few seconds before the door swung open and Brendon’s eye widened at the sight of you.
“Y/N.” he said lifting you into a hug.
“Surprise.” you squeaked out between the tight hold Brendon had on you.
“Brendon share her.” you heard Sarah say next to you.
Brendon put you down and Sarah took you in for a hug.
“I knew you were acting suspicious on the phone. I’m glad you’re here.” he said.
“I wouldn’t miss this for the world. You did amazing and you looked hot in those heels.” you told Brendon.
“You’re such a sneaky bitch. Why didn’t you at least tell me?” Sarah asked faking being insulted.
You laughed for a second before sitting down on the couch with her.
“I wanted it to be a total surprise for both of you.” you said leaning your head on Sarah’s shoulder.
You stayed like that while Brendon finished getting ready to leave.
“So what do you say we go home?” Brendon offered and you quickly stood.
“Sounds good with me. I wanna see the dogs.” you said standing.
Brendon wrapped his arm around your shoulder and pulled you close to him.
“They’ve been missing you, but not as much as me.” he whispered then kissed the top of your head.
When you finally reached home it was pretty late. You three were sitting on the couch together Sarah passed out and Brendon playing with your hair.
“I’m so happy you’re again. We missed you terribly.” Brendon said softly.
“I know, but I had to sort so things out for myself. I think I was just really missing California and how different things are back home.” you explained.
“Well as long as you’re happy I’m happy, and if that means you need to go back to California, we understand. I want the best for you Y/N.” he said.
“Thank you Brendon. You and Sarah mean the world to me. I’m so lucky to have you guys.”
“No, we’re lucky to have you.” Brendon placed a kiss you your head. “I’m going to get Sarah to bed then we can get to bed.” he said when you yawned.
He stood and carried Sarah into the room. You wen tot stand up and go to the room, but Brendon already had you in his arms.
“I have legs you know.” you said.
“And so do I.” he said and put you into the bed.
“I’m aware. Did I tell you how great they looked in those heels?” you said.
“You mentioned it a few times. Good night Y/N, I love you.” he said closing his eyes.
“I love you too.” you said and finally after almost 2 weeks you were happy to be in bed with the ones you loved.