Unlike most teen shows on television, Finchel (Finn & Rachel) Klaine’s (Kurt & Blaine) first times were tender, sweet and almost too private. It was so refreshing to see two couples share such an intimate moment. It wasn’t raunchy or needlessly provocative. It was sweet. It was everything you imagine your first time to be – and everything it SHOULD be – regardless of sexuality.
— Huffington Post review of 3.05 “The First Time.”