Darren criss is checking in the hotel!! American Horror Story: Hotel has reportedly cast Darren Criss for a recurring role in this season’s installment. But what terrifying abomination will Criss play? Maybe a ghoul, a monster, or a freak? Worse—he’ll play a hipster. That’s right, the Glee alum will reportedly join American Horror Story’s ensemble as a Justin, a hipster hailing from Silver Lake. Justin will debut on the season’s Halloween episode (which seems really redundant), where he and his beanie-wearing girlfriend will check into the titular hotel for a night away from trick-or-treaters. And with hipsters being what they are, Justin practically begs Kathy Bates’ character, the owner of the hotel, to make his life a living hell.