it is ethical to mercy-kill any species of animal except for the only one capable of unambiguously communicating a preference for its death over its life
Okay, but what is a “mercy killing” when it comes to humans? Euthanasia? Assisted suicide? Both are legal, to varying degrees. Both have huge systemic problems.
when euthanasia is legal it’s used as a weapon against disabled people and people in poverty, who often “choose” to die to escape the unlivable conditions they were forced into.
Assisted suicide has similar problems. How can you prove that someone really wanted to die, and there was no coercion involved? There’s the fairly famous “texting murder” case, where the victim’s girlfriend encouraged him to kill himself even after he stopped thinking it was a good idea.
There’s inheritance fraud and the systemic lack of mental health care/meds. Retirement homes that cost a lot of money and maybe you just start leaving Grandma pamphlets about going out on her (your) own terms.
Mercy killings for humans would be easily taken advantage of and the definition would be warped. Is killing a POW after months of torture a mercy? Should it still be punishable by law?
Maybe if we had a better economy and healthcare and mental health support, mercy killings for humans would be moral. Now, they’re just another tool to kill off vulnerable people with no consequences.
Hey, out of curiosity, if someone is poor enough that they want to have an abortion even though with financial support they'd prefer to keep the baby, should they be prevented from having an abortion? What if they're being pressured by an outside party? I think just to be safe we should ban abortion until we can be sure no one is ever pressured into it.
not to mention that like, all of the things that have been mentioned *take time*.
by saying "yeah, lets fix the economy, thats gonna take about a decade. in the meantime you are starving, you are living on the street, and you are absolutely miserable every day of your life and constantly put yurself in dangerous situtation to try and kill yourself."
you are advocating for the torture of a human being for a decade n the *promise* the government will get its shit together.
you are advocating for the family that cant afford the nursing home to put grandma in the state run home on medicaid where she gets $60 a month, the worst food on earth and likely abusive staff. You're advocating for them to go broke and grandma to suffer.
"you're suffering now, but we're going to ignore that to try and make the world better" like, no, you make the world better and you let people have agency over their own lives in the meantime.












