Hey remember when I said "you know I thought Sam was a bit mean to Smeagol/Gollum at first but then remembered that he canonically knows that Gollum ate babies and I have to admit I'd be Sam in that situation"
And people were like "no you don't UNDERSTAND there are deeper emotional and symbolic narrative things at play here. It's not about eating babies, Sam doesn't care about him eating babies. It's bigger than that"
And I'm just saying that Sam was a hobbit of the people. A simple down to earth hobbit
And narratively for Frodo there might be some deeper symbolism making him more tortured and needing to be nice to Smeagol/Gollum, but to Sam that guy ate babies and you don't like or trust people who eat babies
And like for having to hang out with a serial killer/baby eater Sam was being relatively chill!
But I am on team Sam with this because if Baby Eater Smythe joined my party and promised to guide us somewhere I would also be so distrustful and aggressive!
He's not even "no I won't eat babies anymore. I think that's bad" Gollum would still eat babies if they were available! He probably ate babies on the way there! He is objectively pro baby eating!
He's not sorry he ate babies and reflecting! He's just like "you have the nuke I want and since you could use it on me I'll play nice" like !!!!!
Frodo is busy being posh and artistic and tortured and being like "the narrative parallels between us are too much! If I knew about the Picture of Dorian Gray and Jekyll and Hyde I'd be making veiled references to them in my diary that I also do not have rn"
Like the guy is going through it. Like a 15 year old traumatised girl with the older boyfriend that she does not like and who treats her like trash but she thinks she deserves (she does not)
Meanwhile Sam is just like "the creepy dude eats babies. Gandalf told Frodo he eats babies when I was 'trimming grass' why are we trusting a guy who eats babies? Frodo I love you but did your arts degree fail to teach you not to trust baby eaters? More importantly he tried to kill you. I was there. This sucks."
TBC I like the story as it is as a story I'm just saying that if I was in Sam's place I would have been worse to the Baby Eater who tried to kill my QueerPlatonic Soulmate