Avatar

i hoped there'd be stars...

@pitynostars / pitynostars.tumblr.com

◑ doctor who sideblog (inc. torchwood, class, sja)

Chibnall Era Survey Responses

Hi everyone! I am delighted to finally have time to share the responses for part 2 and the repeats of part 1. Please let me know if you have any problems viewing the analytics page(s) as I say I didn't have time to do a swanky doc this time around.

Thanks again to everyone who contributed! <3

part 1:

Part 2 (PotD and extra Qs):

Part 1 repeated with Part 2 for those who hadn't filled it out before PotD:

again if you want to credit/see the results as a sheet, please refer to these (please note some have my edits on as i got halfway through before realising i had No time):

So I wanted to include Nardol but apparently the poll has an answer limit on mobile. I left out Dan Lewis because its hard to picture him as a primary companion— if anything he is Yaz's companion. I also left out Mikey, Jack Harkness, and River because while they play a major role they don't seem to meet my arbitrary definition of "primary." And technically Brian Williams was a traveler with the doctor based on all his post cards but that's all off screen.

Reblog to pass it on I'm curious and have no followers

something that i wish thirteen's era had covered more fully are the sheer weirdnesses in this body she regenerated into. why did she regenerate with brown hair that was already half-dyed blonde? how did she have ear piercings as part of a fresh new body? in what world does it make sense for her newly regenerated body to have cleanly shaven legs? thirteen has all these little feminine things going the second she appears, and it's never noticed within the show. and while i guess the masculine-presenting doctors also had little weirdnesses (Ten freshly regenerated with hair gel already applied), it feels more noticeable when the alien doctor falls in so hard with the very specific beauty trends of twenty-first century earth, in every element.

idk i just think having a female doctor could have been room for such growth, but these unspoken little markers that require work and choice being shown as innate and present the minute the doctor appears female strikes me as...i dunno, like guys who think women only look right if they're wearing makeup? like the female-presentation shtick women go through is in any way natural. the thirteenth doctor often seems surprised to be labeled a woman, and yet she's wearing eyeliner. who put that on?

Anonymous asked:

what are the main reasons the chibnall era doesn’t work for you? (not a hater btw, just curious)

Hi anon 🥰 to be honest, I’m still trying to pinpoint it all myself ! While I was thinking about this and writing it out I’ve realised it mainly boils down to:

  • I think a lot of the writing is boring and inconsistent, from characters to big arcs to individual episodes.
  • Too many important character/relationship moments happening offscreen, or just told to us rather than shown to us.
  • So much wasted potential (I think this is the worst part for me because if it was just Bad I wouldn’t be so frustrated by it you know?) I feel like I’ve had more fun in the fandom reading people’s speculations and headcanons all era than watching the actual show itself
  • Sort of in line with that, rehashing of old ideas (+ not doing anything new/interesting with them).
  • I don’t know what it is specifically, whether it’s the writing, acting, or directing, editing, something else, but the whole era has such a patronising vibe to me? All the characters act like stereotypical primary school teachers at their most annoying and it drives me INSANE

So to elaborate:

okay actually i rewatched potd the other day and. i have so many gripes with that episode. so many. but what really got me is how like. inconsequential 13's death feels, and not inconsequential in the right way.

honestly 13's regeneration feels a LOT like 10's, but missing all of the beats that made 10's work. let me explain:

(under a cut because HOLY SHIT this got long. don't let classicists write dr who meta)

hi tell me your take on thasmin

Avatar

hi well. okay. theyre butchfemme theyre tidally locked theyre so repressed and they are also so SO hollow. thasmin as we see in canon is such a disappointment. like what the hell was that! regardless of whether or not they were set up from the start (and I don't believe they were) they are so inconsistent in their dynamic because yasmin is never allowed to be a character. at times she's so weirdly passive for entire episodes which makes her whole relationship with the doctor uncomfortable and upsetting to watch whereas other times she is so competent and capable and implied to be on equal footing with the doctor (yaz can fly the tardis! hello! this is kind of a big deal!) and yet she takes orders and doesnt ever yell at the doctor when she's treated poorly despite very much looking like she would like to! mandip gill gives yaz a lot of depth that just is not there in the writing but it ultimately ends up making me soooooo angry because we truly could have had everything and we didn't. like what's so frustrating is that we consistently get these glimpses of character and a relationship where one person spends four entire years in the past and watches an adaptive hologram of the other person every single day and the whole scene between them implies that they know each other so well that they can predict each others' speech but the hologram is also like a violation of yaz's autonomy? and also these years are colored by so much trauma that she never gets to process and reckon with. and THAT would have been so juicy to explore and we never got to. like thasmin is everything if you do a LOT of extrapolating but the lesbophobia is baked into their writing. incredibly frustrating to say the least when they are so butchfemme (and the doctor wasnt even allowed to properly BE butch it's just that jodie whittaker and mandip gill understand butchfemme thasmin whether they know it or not. this is also where i think a lot of the discourse in the community comes from because theres such a huge discrepancy between the quality of the writing and the quality of the acting) and they ARE so butchfemme. except like...somehow they are less explicitly butchfemme than ninerose and tenrose and it's because those social roles are fundamentally inherently anti-police not palatable to the general public and canon thasmin is nothing if not palatable

Avatar

two characters who understand each other like no one else does and therefore hurt each other like no one else can

i'm being so fucking normal about the imaginary people that i made up in my head

Chibnall Era Survey Responses

Hi everyone! I am delighted to finally have time to share the responses for part 2 and the repeats of part 1. Please let me know if you have any problems viewing the analytics page(s) as I say I didn't have time to do a swanky doc this time around.

Thanks again to everyone who contributed! <3

part 1:

Part 2 (PotD and extra Qs):

Part 1 repeated with Part 2 for those who hadn't filled it out before PotD:

again if you want to credit/see the results as a sheet, please refer to these (please note some have my edits on as i got halfway through before realising i had No time):