The 2022-2023 Romanian non-replica production at the Opera Nationala in Bucharest, designed by Gary McCann
I have been pondering back and forth. It’s one of those designs I like on an intellectual level, and whose opulence is absolutely fascinating. Yet... yet I don’t really love it. First time I saw photos of it was in the flood of every friend ever trying out AI technology, generating all kinds of photos and scenarios. This felt much in the same vein. Fantastical, crowded, grand, slightly acid-trip. I scrolled past it all, and never really posted anything about it on Tumblr. But it keeps re-appearing now and then and eventually I had to analyze what I saw.
To my surprise AI is exactly what the designer has used. He explains in his Instagram that:
“All the various components have been individually generated using Midjourneyai (V3) and then combined by myself in Photoshop and Cinema4d . V3 has a rather weird and expressionist feel to it which I felt was appropriate.”
“The right-hand side (of the proscenium, my note) is deliberately designed to look damaged - angels are missing heads, arms, bits of wings, and the heavy floral swags are broken. The prosc therefore symbolises the Phantoms face.”
And I like this on an intellectual level. It’s clever, and a modern approach to a classic tale. There’s something deeply fascinating about the world of the Phantom, that impossible fantasy world, recreated in a purely digital medium translated onto stage.
But again... I’m not loving it. Apart from being slightly exhausted by AI generated content, I also think the rounded shapes, bold colours and uhm... lack of blank spaces makes it overwhelming. Seeing photos of the sets without the cast and with the cast made me realize there’s not really room for people in this design. Everything is just a tad crowded and overblown. Which I realize is on purpose, to keep the AI fantay world look, so mission completed in that aspect.
There is no denying that this is an original and so very rich-looking take on designing the Phantom. I do appreciate a lot of aspects of it, and would have loved to see how it works live. Which is what it was designed for, after all. But from the photos alone I do appreciate the dark shadows and blank spaces of Maria Bjørnson even more.
(bonus for Adrian Nour and Irina Ioana Baiant from the original Romanian production repeating their roles, in a totally different staging, and extra bonus for one of the biggest orchestra in Phantom history... 72 musicians!)